Hello,
I am returning to provide Drawing Workspace feedback after perhaps 12 months, which have not been addressed yet. The point of this post is to reiterate key drawing functions that need to be implemented and inversely drawing components in the current Fusion 360 drawing module that need to be eliminated.
Comparison Criteria:
I have used a number of drawing softwares over the years. AutoDesk products and Dassault. Of those, Solidworks has been one of the smoothest most fluent tools for generate a print. It is fast, clean, powerful, and easy. That said, much of my basis for criteria will be similar to SW.
Assumptions and Reality:
The market for F360 is primarily hobbyist / small business customers, I am assuming. With a minority of it's market being medium to large businesses. Nonetheless, this software is being sold and used commercially. We can agree on that... Because its being used commercially and sold for a price, I would assume Autodesk's intent for F360 is to be a serious drawing tool? As in -- used in the real world?
Reality is that 2D drawings remain the international engineering standard for conveying mechanical part requirements. The 2D drawing is the end-all, be-all in most manufacturing environments. And will be for a long time. You can sculpt and design all you want. You can be a pro! But if you can't put that on paper... forget it.
Fusion's Drawing environment is the most under-developed, most-lacking component in it's suite. My opinon: forget all the fancy-dancy other stuff thats being developed in other modules and put them on HOLD. Those workspaces are more than adequate today.
With that said, I hope you will not just consider my ideas below, but you will actually pursue them. Allocate resources to get these things done. Thank you.
DISCLAIMER: If any of the below has been resolved or is resolve-able as the software stands today, please let me know. Thanks
1.) Fluency
Worst part of Drawing in F360 is how terribly choppy performance is-- object flickering, "grid-like" movement of objects in the space. This module should be so efficient that its like pushing a hockey puck on a smooth sheet of ice, or dragging a desktop icon to another spot. Real-time feedback when you drag an object, and fluent movement.
P.S. I'm on a very powerful machine.
2.) Snapping Dimensions
Snapping dimensions is a feature no one wants. Its cumbersome and annoying. A dim should be placed and able to be moved freely wherever, with very few constraints.
3.) Construction Geometry via Sketch
You can't construct geometry with a sketch. This is blasphemy! You are selling this product commercially and cannot construct geometry with a sketch?
4.) View Labeling
Lets allow custom view designators. "Section View A-A 1:1"... What if I want "Section View S-S 1:1" Why can't I change A to S?
5.) Section View
I've never seen something so difficult. Make it easy like SW did... Select the type of section view you want: Horizontal, Vertical, or Custom. One point to snap the section view line to and wah-lah. Custom would be how you have it now (a "free" type of section view where you can define a more irregular profile. ).
6.) Break View
Lets implement break view. This is critical.
7.) Detail Views are ugly
Make details views like SW. They know detail views... The view perimeter options should be: Round, Square, or From Construction. The style options should be: Arrows (current), With Leader, or No leader. Other options should be: No border.
8.) Auto Linear Dimension Alignment
Rather than click "Aligned Dimension" Fusion 360 should give me the option of aligned or vertical/horizontal. This is relatively easy code, I imagine. Check to see if the elements are vertically or horizontally aligned, if not, turn on aligned dimension.
9.) Default Drawing Settings
There should be an entire list of defaults you can adjust. Examples might be: Section View Label text size, Styles for Views, etc.
Conclusion:
Well, that is all for today. More to be added to this post as time goes on. Please implement these features. Afterall, its the drawing that is what matters!
Thanks for listening,
Regards
Show More