Advance Steel Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Advance Steel Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular Advance Steel topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Advance Steel custom commands-share your ideas

814 REPLIES 814
SOLVED
Reply
Message 1 of 815
acbsdesign
93925 Views, 814 Replies

Advance Steel custom commands-share your ideas

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

Hello,

It will be nice to learn more about custom commands / combination of Autocad and Advance Steel commands improving productivity. 

To colleagues willing to share-Thank you.

 

Here is a tiny example:

"Hide parts with identical numbers"-used when parts are detailed using drawings styles.

 

^C^C_AstM5equalpartsMarkSame \;AstM4CommSelectMarkedObjects ;_AstM4SwitchReprMode off

 

And another one:

"Hide Similar Advance Steel Objects":

^C^C_SelectSimilar \;_AstM4SwitchReprMode off

 

Regards, 

Ilko Dimitrov

ACBS

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Advance Steel custom commands-share your ideas

Hello,

It will be nice to learn more about custom commands / combination of Autocad and Advance Steel commands improving productivity. 

To colleagues willing to share-Thank you.

 

Here is a tiny example:

"Hide parts with identical numbers"-used when parts are detailed using drawings styles.

 

^C^C_AstM5equalpartsMarkSame \;AstM4CommSelectMarkedObjects ;_AstM4SwitchReprMode off

 

And another one:

"Hide Similar Advance Steel Objects":

^C^C_SelectSimilar \;_AstM4SwitchReprMode off

 

Regards, 

Ilko Dimitrov

ACBS

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



814 REPLIES 814
Message 701 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@dave_conibear 

 

I have one similar, "Clean model"

 

^C^C _AstM4CommSelectAllDscObjects ALL _AstM10ViewSelObjects OBJECTS _AstM4SelectObjectByName;ASTXWORKINGPLANE,ASTUSERDIALOG,ASTXDIALOG,ASTXMODELVIEW,ASTWELD,ASTXSTRUCTURALBOX,ASTXBEAMFEAT,ASTXPLATEFEAT,ASTXASTXBEAMSHORTENING;AstM4SwitchReprMode;off _AstM4CommUnmarkObjects^M;

 

 

HTH

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



0 Likes

@dave_conibear 

 

I have one similar, "Clean model"

 

^C^C _AstM4CommSelectAllDscObjects ALL _AstM10ViewSelObjects OBJECTS _AstM4SelectObjectByName;ASTXWORKINGPLANE,ASTUSERDIALOG,ASTXDIALOG,ASTXMODELVIEW,ASTWELD,ASTXSTRUCTURALBOX,ASTXBEAMFEAT,ASTXPLATEFEAT,ASTXASTXBEAMSHORTENING;AstM4SwitchReprMode;off _AstM4CommUnmarkObjects^M;

 

 

HTH

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 702 of 815
mick-CNF
in reply to: markhubrich

mick-CNF
Advisor
Advisor

^C^C_AstM4SelectObjectByName_ ASTSCREWBOLTPATTERN_ AstM4SwitchReprMode

 

For bolts.

I've tried something similar for anchors but never got it to work.

If this information solves your problem please accept as a solution.

^C^C_AstM4SelectObjectByName_ ASTSCREWBOLTPATTERN_ AstM4SwitchReprMode

 

For bolts.

I've tried something similar for anchors but never got it to work.

If this information solves your problem please accept as a solution.
Message 703 of 815
bigcarl5000kg
in reply to: markhubrich

bigcarl5000kg
Advisor
Advisor

Hi @markhubrich,

 

have a look here:

 

https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/advance-steel-forum/user-defined-representation-mode-change/m-p/10338...

+++ impossible immediately and miracles within 3 days +++
+++ the only constant is the change +++ stay tuned for more +++
+++ since 03/2023 is Advance Steel in maintenance mode, no further development +++

Hi @markhubrich,

 

have a look here:

 

https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/advance-steel-forum/user-defined-representation-mode-change/m-p/10338...

+++ impossible immediately and miracles within 3 days +++
+++ the only constant is the change +++ stay tuned for more +++
+++ since 03/2023 is Advance Steel in maintenance mode, no further development +++
Message 704 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@dave_conibear 

 

 

^C^C AstM4CommSelectAllDscObjects_ _AstM10ViewSelObjects OBJECTS;

 

and requires Esc. It works when placed in ACAD toolpalette.

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



@dave_conibear 

 

 

^C^C AstM4CommSelectAllDscObjects_ _AstM10ViewSelObjects OBJECTS;

 

and requires Esc. It works when placed in ACAD toolpalette.

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 705 of 815
dave_conibear
in reply to: acbsdesign

dave_conibear
Advocate
Advocate

Christ..............it works..........

You can't possibly imagine what you have just done for me

I have that in my "right click" shortcut menu.

I'm working at the moment on a not so straight forward spiral stair and there are a million construction lines and parts of the architects 3-D AutoCad model model in my model, and that command will save me as much time as "Save & Close" command you posts very near to the beginning of this thread.

Thank you again Ilko for replying

Christ..............it works..........

You can't possibly imagine what you have just done for me

I have that in my "right click" shortcut menu.

I'm working at the moment on a not so straight forward spiral stair and there are a million construction lines and parts of the architects 3-D AutoCad model model in my model, and that command will save me as much time as "Save & Close" command you posts very near to the beginning of this thread.

Thank you again Ilko for replying

Message 706 of 815

MetallPlanMerkinger
Enthusiast
Enthusiast
Accepted solution

Hello!

I do this with Layers. I create for the architect drawings different layers, whicht all begins with "XREF_.......", and then i switch them on or off with freezing or thawing.

with a custom Command, that freezes or thawes all layers which starts with "XREF"

thawing: ^C^C_-LAYER;T;XREF* ^C^C

freezing: ^C^C_-LAYER;F;XREF* ^C^C

so you can also switch them on or off very fast

MetallPlanMerkinger_0-1675189382619.png

MetallPlanMerkinger_1-1675189393398.png

 

For exaple, this works also at this way, here i am freezing and thawing a Layer set from special layers i often have to switch:

^C^C_-LAYER;T;AS_Schweißen,AS_KAMERAS,AS_Anschlussboxen,AS_Modellansichten ^C^C

^C^C_-LAYER;F;AS_Schweißen,AS_KAMERAS,AS_Anschlussboxen,AS_Modellansichten ^C^C

 

Hello!

I do this with Layers. I create for the architect drawings different layers, whicht all begins with "XREF_.......", and then i switch them on or off with freezing or thawing.

with a custom Command, that freezes or thawes all layers which starts with "XREF"

thawing: ^C^C_-LAYER;T;XREF* ^C^C

freezing: ^C^C_-LAYER;F;XREF* ^C^C

so you can also switch them on or off very fast

MetallPlanMerkinger_0-1675189382619.png

MetallPlanMerkinger_1-1675189393398.png

 

For exaple, this works also at this way, here i am freezing and thawing a Layer set from special layers i often have to switch:

^C^C_-LAYER;T;AS_Schweißen,AS_KAMERAS,AS_Anschlussboxen,AS_Modellansichten ^C^C

^C^C_-LAYER;F;AS_Schweißen,AS_KAMERAS,AS_Anschlussboxen,AS_Modellansichten ^C^C

 

Message 707 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@MetallPlanMerkinger 

I was ready to say ideas are slowing down.

 

This is awesome.

 

Thank you for sharing and have a great day.

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



@MetallPlanMerkinger 

I was ready to say ideas are slowing down.

 

This is awesome.

 

Thank you for sharing and have a great day.

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 708 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: dave_conibear

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@dave_conibear wrote:

Christ..............it works..........

You can't possibly imagine what you have just done for me

I have that in my "right click" shortcut menu.

I'm working at the moment on a not so straight forward spiral stair and there are a million construction lines and parts of the architects 3-D AutoCad model model in my model, and that command will save me as much time as "Save & Close" command you posts very near to the beginning of this thread.

Thank you again Ilko for replying


 

You are welcome Dave. Glad it worked.

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



0 Likes


@dave_conibear wrote:

Christ..............it works..........

You can't possibly imagine what you have just done for me

I have that in my "right click" shortcut menu.

I'm working at the moment on a not so straight forward spiral stair and there are a million construction lines and parts of the architects 3-D AutoCad model model in my model, and that command will save me as much time as "Save & Close" command you posts very near to the beginning of this thread.

Thank you again Ilko for replying


 

You are welcome Dave. Glad it worked.

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 709 of 815

MetallPlanMerkinger
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

@acbsdesign 

o no, there are many other ideas:

do you know this one -> grouped saw list with pictures:

I have grouped that list in combination with material and Beam Name

:clinking_beer_mugs:

MetallPlanMerkinger_0-1675192218377.png

 

@acbsdesign 

o no, there are many other ideas:

do you know this one -> grouped saw list with pictures:

I have grouped that list in combination with material and Beam Name

:clinking_beer_mugs:

MetallPlanMerkinger_0-1675192218377.png

 

Message 710 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@MetallPlanMerkinger 

 

Will try to combine them, never thought about this.

Thank you for sharing.

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



0 Likes

@MetallPlanMerkinger 

 

Will try to combine them, never thought about this.

Thank you for sharing.

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 711 of 815

MetallPlanMerkinger
Enthusiast
Enthusiast
Accepted solution

another one is:

MetallPlanMerkinger_0-1675194338700.png

 

i put on every overview Layouts a QR-Code with the 3D Model. Today everyone has a smartphone, and thats very helpful for every bulding worker, to find assembly numbers, or screws....

I export the 3d model as dwfx, save it on Autodesk drive, create a link, and put this link in the qr code, and also link the code, that it is possible to click from the pdf.

 

For creating the qr code, there is a free app in the autodesk store, with changes the text in qr code

 

https://apps.autodesk.com/ACD/de/Detail/Index?id=7854648785059363913&appLang=en&os=Win32_64

 

 

another one is:

MetallPlanMerkinger_0-1675194338700.png

 

i put on every overview Layouts a QR-Code with the 3D Model. Today everyone has a smartphone, and thats very helpful for every bulding worker, to find assembly numbers, or screws....

I export the 3d model as dwfx, save it on Autodesk drive, create a link, and put this link in the qr code, and also link the code, that it is possible to click from the pdf.

 

For creating the qr code, there is a free app in the autodesk store, with changes the text in qr code

 

https://apps.autodesk.com/ACD/de/Detail/Index?id=7854648785059363913&appLang=en&os=Win32_64

 

 

Message 712 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor


@MetallPlanMerkinger 

@markhubrich Posted a great idea about using Navisworks and exporting to dwf.

 

I export to Navisworks and place the QR on E-dwgs in an XREF that will stay forever in prototypes.

 

Navisworks keeps grid lines and AS properties. But if it has to be super shiny, I use dwf.

 

Thank you for sharing.

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place





@MetallPlanMerkinger 

@markhubrich Posted a great idea about using Navisworks and exporting to dwf.

 

I export to Navisworks and place the QR on E-dwgs in an XREF that will stay forever in prototypes.

 

Navisworks keeps grid lines and AS properties. But if it has to be super shiny, I use dwf.

 

Thank you for sharing.

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 713 of 815
bigcarl5000kg
in reply to: acbsdesign

bigcarl5000kg
Advisor
Advisor
Accepted solution

Hi all,

 

if someone wants to show the center of gravity in the drawing, for all objects in the model space, here is a LISP code from @Kent1Cooper   - many thanks for your help.

 

In the LISP, there is the Advance Steel command for center of gravity (_astm4balancepoint) already implemented and this adds a point (ACAD object) in the model area. As next, one sphere solid object (ACIS) is inserted at coordinates from this point. LISP also checks whether such a sphere object exists in the model space and if the position of the center of gravity changes (new point inserted), it moves the sphere object to this new point - I hope I described it correctly 😁.

 

Additional ACIS body (sphere solid) could be implemented in drawing style and then automatically displayed, possibly described and dimensioned inkl. updates.

 

Changed version - ucs set to world, to prevent center of gravity rotation, if ucs rotated before:

 

 

(defun C:SACOG ; = Sphere At Center of Gravity
  (/ COG ss sph)
  (command "_ucs" "")
  (command "_astm4balancepoint")
  (setq COG (getpropertyvalue (entlast) "Position")); location of Point
  (if (setq ss (ssget "_X" '((0 . "3DSOLID")))); Sphere already exists in drawing
    (progn ; then -- Move it
      (setq sph (ssname ss 0))
      (command "_.move" sph ""
        "_non" (vlax-get (vlax-ename->vla-object sph) 'Centroid)
        "_non" COG
      ); command
    ); progn
    (command "_.sphere" "_non" COG 30); else -- draw it <---EDIT [radius from 30 dia. Message 1]
  ); if
  (prin1)
)

 

 

 

 

+++ impossible immediately and miracles within 3 days +++
+++ the only constant is the change +++ stay tuned for more +++
+++ since 03/2023 is Advance Steel in maintenance mode, no further development +++

Hi all,

 

if someone wants to show the center of gravity in the drawing, for all objects in the model space, here is a LISP code from @Kent1Cooper   - many thanks for your help.

 

In the LISP, there is the Advance Steel command for center of gravity (_astm4balancepoint) already implemented and this adds a point (ACAD object) in the model area. As next, one sphere solid object (ACIS) is inserted at coordinates from this point. LISP also checks whether such a sphere object exists in the model space and if the position of the center of gravity changes (new point inserted), it moves the sphere object to this new point - I hope I described it correctly 😁.

 

Additional ACIS body (sphere solid) could be implemented in drawing style and then automatically displayed, possibly described and dimensioned inkl. updates.

 

Changed version - ucs set to world, to prevent center of gravity rotation, if ucs rotated before:

 

 

(defun C:SACOG ; = Sphere At Center of Gravity
  (/ COG ss sph)
  (command "_ucs" "")
  (command "_astm4balancepoint")
  (setq COG (getpropertyvalue (entlast) "Position")); location of Point
  (if (setq ss (ssget "_X" '((0 . "3DSOLID")))); Sphere already exists in drawing
    (progn ; then -- Move it
      (setq sph (ssname ss 0))
      (command "_.move" sph ""
        "_non" (vlax-get (vlax-ename->vla-object sph) 'Centroid)
        "_non" COG
      ); command
    ); progn
    (command "_.sphere" "_non" COG 30); else -- draw it <---EDIT [radius from 30 dia. Message 1]
  ); if
  (prin1)
)

 

 

 

 

+++ impossible immediately and miracles within 3 days +++
+++ the only constant is the change +++ stay tuned for more +++
+++ since 03/2023 is Advance Steel in maintenance mode, no further development +++
Message 714 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

Fellows 30 and younger-please disregard. 

Not a custom command, but saves time and far less strain on 

acbsdesign_1-1676062832611.png

 

Single-click in Windows explorer in lieu of double click. Point to select. +Underline icons only when pointed at them.

 

acbsdesign_0-1676062671679.png

 

It takes a few days to get used to it, but overall it is a time and wrist+tendons saver.

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Fellows 30 and younger-please disregard. 

Not a custom command, but saves time and far less strain on 

acbsdesign_1-1676062832611.png

 

Single-click in Windows explorer in lieu of double click. Point to select. +Underline icons only when pointed at them.

 

acbsdesign_0-1676062671679.png

 

It takes a few days to get used to it, but overall it is a time and wrist+tendons saver.

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 715 of 815
vuk.vukanic
in reply to: acbsdesign

vuk.vukanic
Collaborator
Collaborator
Accepted solution

Ok, here is one that uses QR code generator, but to check drawing status:

UP TO DATE / OBSOLETE

I have 2 images with the name “Status.png”, one indicates “Up to date” and one “Obsolete” drawings.

       

vukvukanic_0-1676902601674.png    vukvukanic_1-1676902601675.png

 

Here how it works:

I place a QR code with link to my gdrive folder where all project items are located to point to “Status.png”. It is important to note that every revision has a separate folder and a separate “Status.png” file.

 

When a new Revision is created and uploaded to gdrive I just replace the UP TO DATE “Status.png” with OBSOLETE “Status.png” image from the previous revision.

 

Since I use xrefed .dwg (that contains the QR code) in my Prototypes, I can replace the QR code in no time at all after all drawings are generated. I cant find the post where I described this, but I did a webinar a while back (not in english) where the xref prototypes are illustrated (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0eGaCsgDNLw).

 

I thought about doing it for each drawing, but didn’t find a practical solution that I’m capable of executing.


Easy things are not worth the effort
http://www.teamcad.rs

Ok, here is one that uses QR code generator, but to check drawing status:

UP TO DATE / OBSOLETE

I have 2 images with the name “Status.png”, one indicates “Up to date” and one “Obsolete” drawings.

       

vukvukanic_0-1676902601674.png    vukvukanic_1-1676902601675.png

 

Here how it works:

I place a QR code with link to my gdrive folder where all project items are located to point to “Status.png”. It is important to note that every revision has a separate folder and a separate “Status.png” file.

 

When a new Revision is created and uploaded to gdrive I just replace the UP TO DATE “Status.png” with OBSOLETE “Status.png” image from the previous revision.

 

Since I use xrefed .dwg (that contains the QR code) in my Prototypes, I can replace the QR code in no time at all after all drawings are generated. I cant find the post where I described this, but I did a webinar a while back (not in english) where the xref prototypes are illustrated (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0eGaCsgDNLw).

 

I thought about doing it for each drawing, but didn’t find a practical solution that I’m capable of executing.


Easy things are not worth the effort
http://www.teamcad.rs
Message 716 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@vuk.vukanic 

Thank you for sharing.

We will use this idea.

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



@vuk.vukanic 

Thank you for sharing.

We will use this idea.

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 717 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

Dynamic block for most commonly used welds, 

hope some may find it easier and more accurate than the AS default weld symbols.

Dwg attached. Anyone with an improvement-please repost here so we can all use it.

 

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Dynamic block for most commonly used welds, 

hope some may find it easier and more accurate than the AS default weld symbols.

Dwg attached. Anyone with an improvement-please repost here so we can all use it.

 

 

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 718 of 815

Sebastian_Eiche
Mentor
Mentor

I really understand the easy use of this block, but just for me: why don't you use the AS weld symbol?
the symbol could be changed very easy and additional welds are also possible with the databases. 
For my point of view, it would be easier to created the weld as modelobject in the model to have the symbol in the detail updateable


Sebastian Eiche
Application Engineer @Mensch und Maschine acadGraph

EESignature

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this make it easier for other users

I really understand the easy use of this block, but just for me: why don't you use the AS weld symbol?
the symbol could be changed very easy and additional welds are also possible with the databases. 
For my point of view, it would be easier to created the weld as modelobject in the model to have the symbol in the detail updateable


Sebastian Eiche
Application Engineer @Mensch und Maschine acadGraph

EESignature

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this make it easier for other users

Message 719 of 815
acbsdesign
in reply to: acbsdesign

acbsdesign
Mentor
Mentor

@Sebastian_Eiche 

Hi, no, AS symbols do not meet AWS requirements for size, text, position

. Tale size and shape.

As a matter of fact the look funny.

Especially for CJP and PJP welds.

Made a few requests, some improvements but incomplete.

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



@Sebastian_Eiche 

Hi, no, AS symbols do not meet AWS requirements for size, text, position

. Tale size and shape.

As a matter of fact the look funny.

Especially for CJP and PJP welds.

Made a few requests, some improvements but incomplete.

 

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this makes it easier for other users.

Regards,
Ilko Dimitrov, IDC-1, M. Eng.
Tekla and Advance Steel Detailer
ACBS Structural Steel Detailing

If it is made of steel, I can model it and detail it.

acbs-usa.com | Helpful Place



Message 720 of 815

Sebastian_Eiche
Mentor
Mentor

Ok, I know the symbol don't fit, but the symbols could be changed in size and so on. 
I mean, if the result with the dynamic block works for you I don't want to convince you 🙂 
The problem from my point of view: if something is changed, the detaillers had to know which details should be changed. With a model object, the changing is mcuh easier, but if the result is not ok, your way is better


Sebastian Eiche
Application Engineer @Mensch und Maschine acadGraph

EESignature

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this make it easier for other users

0 Likes

Ok, I know the symbol don't fit, but the symbols could be changed in size and so on. 
I mean, if the result with the dynamic block works for you I don't want to convince you 🙂 
The problem from my point of view: if something is changed, the detaillers had to know which details should be changed. With a model object, the changing is mcuh easier, but if the result is not ok, your way is better


Sebastian Eiche
Application Engineer @Mensch und Maschine acadGraph

EESignature

If this information was helpful, please use the Accept as Solution function, this make it easier for other users

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Autodesk Design & Make Report