Announcements
Welcome to the Revit Ideas Board! Before posting, please read the helpful tips here. Thank you for your Ideas!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Stairs: more functionality

Stairs: more functionality

Reposting @FinearcLtd since Autodesk marked his intital post as "Implemented" yet none of the requests in his post have been answered.

 

https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/revit-ideas/stairs-stairs-please-make-them-professional/idc-p/6802543...

 

"I would be a blessing to have the stair tool more robust and full of parameters that allow one to create a detailed and exact staircase. Adding core and finish layers as you would in a wall. Determining the end conditions more precisely, with better control. The more detailing control the merrier."

 

I can't believe Autodesk even had the audacity to say this post is "Implemented", the current changes (multi-story) are nowhere near what was requested.

2 Comments
Anonymous
Not applicable

Thanks for re-posting this.  I can't believe we are now at release 2018 and we don't yet have a better tools for stairs. Thanks for the added multistory support, but that was way down the list of required changes IMHO.  We need much more detailed control over these elements.  I feel like since the introduction of component stairs we have actually gone backwards in terms of available workarounds.  For example, just try extending a stringer support beyond the end of the stair to allow proper trimming and anchoring to floor structure.  Or how about modeling a short tread at the top of a run to allow for proper support member joining at the landings. Can't do that anymore either.  It's not that the tools can't generate a clean looking set of stairs and railings, they just can't generate a stair that reflects how it will actually be constructed. They are a nice pictorial approximation of stairs. Pure bubble gum. Not exactly the quality you would want from a precision BIM application. There are too many tight tolerances that impact building code clearances etc. to continue trusting the current tool set.  Honestly it seems some days it would be better to just model stairs by hand, at least then you could have control and ensure they are constructable, code compliant etc. 

 

Please Autodesk get this fixed!

RyanBradley_JACOBS
Contributor

Stairs are definitely one of those things that make us all envious of Archicad users....

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea