Announcements
Welcome to the Revit Ideas Board! Before posting, please read the helpful tips here. Thank you for your Ideas!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Non-rectangular Scope Box

Non-rectangular Scope Box

We have non-rectangular crop regions.  Can we please have non-rectangular scope boxes so we don't have to copy/paste the non-rectangular crop region to 30 views.......

151 Comments
fhessler
Explorer

I'll add my vote to this as well.

Filax007
Observer

I'll dedicate my first post to this. For multi story apartment buildings non rectangular scope boxes would be a game changer, I'm sure you realize this so please implement it.

CTaylorCCE
Contributor

I've posted before, but I wanted to share a method I use to get around this in the meantime.  I have pre-created detail groups from chains of detail lines.  I place these detail groups in a view that needs to be irregular, select the detail group "CropX" and the view boundary, and "HI" to isolate.  Then I Edit Crop of the view and align/trim/draw crop lines to match.  "HR" to reset view Hide/Isolate, and delete the detail group from view.

 

As an alternative to pre-created detail groups, one could create model lines and model groups in each level, then they would not need to be placed in each view.

A second alternative would be to use reference planes, as they can extend across multiple floors.  But depending on your view templates and Reference Plane visibility settings you may need to place them on a different layer workset and "improperly" use worksets, according to Revit engineers.

I hope this helps someone along the way.  If there's a better place to share this, please educate me.

kcannon7SM62
Participant

@CTaylorCCE, that is a really good idea! I've done custom crop regions before, but never by using a group or detail lines to copy it from level to level. I'll definitely be using this next time I have an oddly shaped building. Thanks!

 

As for worksets, we use them "improperly" all the time, so I'm not worried about that.

ktaltd
Enthusiast

Hi 

It is a really good idea that has been going since 2016. Sadly, I do not think it will ever come to fruition as Revit is now over twenty years old,  -  Major development has stalled over the last ten years and the program should have been rewritten by now if it is ever was going to be rewritten. There are a few issues like this that will never be addressed. - Now we have Forma and the resources seem to be going into this and the cloud.  Accelerating developments in AI will probably mean that the Revit platform will be gone in five to ten years.  Maybe Autodesk will be lucky to survive?

Harris_Josh
Contributor

Bumping this thread. There are infinite examples of buildings with irregular shapes. Producing those buildings in Revit without irregular scope boxes is a hinderance to productivity. Please get this on the roadmap and help the community save their beautiful heads of hair before they pull them out. 

nmarcelis
Advisor

This would be a great addition to revit

nmarcelis
Advisor

@DMK™that are some nice visuals.

ksmithBMBHQ
Participant

I'm starting to think scope boxes might need a complete overhaul. The fact that they still have no API support (despite people suggesting it as long as a decade ago) probably means that the way they're defined in the source code is probably quite troublesome and hard to add functionality to. Autodesk, let's get some smarter scope boxes! Start from the ground up if you need to! Scope boxes for the win

nicklovell
Participant

This would be so easy to implement and they still won't do it. I bet I could code it myself. The perils of a monopoly.

vitorbortoncello
Collaborator

editable scope box shape

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea  

Forma Design Contest


Technology Administrators