Announcements
Welcome to the Revit Ideas Board! Before posting, please read the helpful tips here. Thank you for your Ideas!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Array with Optional Start and End Elements

Array with Optional Start and End Elements

Often when working with arrays, I want to spread elements evenly between two reference planes, but not have an element at one or both reference planes. Currently to make this happen, I have to add another reference plane a calculated distance from the "end" reference plane and attach my arrays to that, and do lots of math and formulas. Also, if I want "1 element in the middle" to be an option, the array breaks so I have to control it with visibility settings and it gets complicated. This could all be solved if there was an option in arrays to turn off the end or beginning elements. Nothing else would have to change. So for my "1 element in the middle" problem, the array number would be three. One at the ends that aren't visible, and one in the middle. 

9 Comments
awasyliw
Advocate

Alternatively you could have offset parameters for the beginning and end items of the array, which would give more functionality/control than just turning the ned items on or off.

colinqBYUV9
Enthusiast

I'd like to be able to array from a centre element too. 

 

1 directional array or 2 directional array.

JordiCC245
Contributor

actually you can do a patch, excluding the first array element from its group.  I know it's not a solid solution and may have several limitations, but maybe it can help in some cases meanwhile

mhiserZFHXS
Advisor

Everything posted here, by OP and others, is already possible. The one improvement that would be a big time saver and lighten up families is the ability to have a 0 or 1 elements in an array, and that's on the roadmap now. Everything else can be done with a couple of parameters and formulas.

colinqBYUV9
Enthusiast

@mhiserZFHXS,

 

Agreed that 0 & 1 would help enormously. Can you point me in the direction of the ways to array from the centre, exclude the first & last in an array etc. as above? 

JordiCC245
Contributor

 

 

 

 

 

 

mhiserZFHXS
Advisor

@colinqBYUV9You can't just think of it as "exclude first and/or last" or "array from center". Those are your goals. You need to use visibility parameters, offset dimensions, formulas and logic to figure out how to reach those goals. I don't have time to walk you through how to do those things step by step right now. But if you're really struggling, I suggest posting about it on the user forum. Someone will help you there, or maybe I can get to it later.

 

While I wouldn't necessarily complain about Autodesk taking the time to put things in that do these actions at the click of a button, I would much rather them spend time on things that are completely impossible, like tagging legends, or things that have the potential to break families like arrays of 0 or 1.

colinqBYUV9
Enthusiast

@mhiserZFHXS Thanks for the reply. I'm aware of using visibilities, If's & And formulas etc. in families. I thought you might know of something simpler that I don't know about. And what about a typical design situation like arraying carparks or furniture out from a centre point in a project? 

 

When autodesk is rolling out analysis tools, generative design, cloud products etc. simple everyday usability tools seem to be ignored. 

colinqBYUV9
Enthusiast

Nice, thanks @JordiCC245

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea