Save Our RSA

[mustafahesenow]

Hi my friends,

To save RSA and to inform Autodesk that we really love RSA and its the best software ever and you need to keep developing it and improve it more and more.

I am trying to raise our voice and send it to the highest person on Autodesk to let them understand that they have to focus on RSA not to cancel it.

There fore I am trying to collect the voices from our lovely forum. If you are interested in this issue Please send me your feedback and

your contact details to my personal mail (mustafahesenow@gmail.com).

Name , work , your name on RSA forum, and personal mail, and your phone number.

Many thanks for your collaboration.

We love RSA and we will do our best to save it.

Eng.Mustafa Hesenow

[mustafahesenow]

Hi @gustavo_c_vasconcellos

Thanks For sending us my friend,

Please send me your details as well to my personal mail mustafahesenow@gmail.com

Awaiting for you guys. 

Please stand with us to save our RSA.

[alfredmx]

Hello Friends,

Great initiative Mustafa Hesenow! Please let me know if I can be of any help. We are RSA users since Robot Millennium v15.

Regards,

[Rafacascudo]

V13.5 here!!!😆😆😆
Good to hear from you @alfredmx

[mustafahesenow]

Hi @alfredmx

Thanks for participating with us my friend,

Please send me your details to include your voice with us in order to save our RSA.

see the required detail in the beginning of this thread and forward it to my mail there please.

Many thanks for your collaboration.

[WorldDue]

I am not updated, did Auto-desk stop its development or are they just gonna make it an add-in for the rest of their software?

[mustafahesenow]

Hi @WorldDue

yes it’s going so please send me your details to include your voice to save our 

Rsa

many thanks for collaboration 

[Nairi85]

Great idea. I, too, have connected to the movement for the RSA. I very much hope that it will be possible to achieve positive results. Robot is the best!

[mustafahesenow]

Hi Guys,

Please dont stop on step of giving kudos only.Please participate with us and share your detail and experience with RSA.

[Anonymous]

Hi mustafahesenov,

I fully support your initiative. RSA is powerful tool for all kind of structures. There is obvious intention by Autodesk to implement structural design in Revit but it is not clear why they try to push something that is not fully compatible. 

Structural design is something that requires a lot of theoretical and practical knowledge, it's not just the tool in question. I am quite new Robot user, but I feel comfortable to say that Robot is one of the best available structural softwers. If Autodesk want to motivate structural engineers  to use all other softwares they have to continuously develop new features in Robot. First contact with any softwers start on the faculty, usually solving static problems.

And when young engineers starts with Robot then the next step could be Revit, Advance steel etc. So main assumption for theaching all other Autodesk tools (as Advance steel, Concrete and Revit) usually starts from powerfull and user friendly structural analysis. 

From my point of view Revit can not be that structural design tool, it can be good pre-processor, nothing more. 

Most important is that Robot is brand in structural design and if it loses that status, then Revit will have to change the strategy...

Regards

[mustafahesenow]

Hi @Anonymous

You are absolutely correct. I can assure to you that Revit  wont work as structural analysis software.They are dreaming in something not possible.

Revit not Hero . But RSA yes . 

[Iron.Max.Steel]

What was then now the structural software of autodesk if ever they will not continue robot? Actually im staad user but now im switching tp robo cause im tired of the kind of development they do with staad, now its looks its a bad news for me 😞

[mustafahesenow]

Hi @Iron.Max.Steel

We can stop this plan and keep RSA remained.

Please send me your details in order to include your voice with us .

mustafahesenow@gmail.com.

[mathias_peron]

Robot must be a priorty for Autodesk.

[Refaat]

Also , me V15 ROBOT Millennium .  

Refaat 

[tom.krok]

Robot - one of the most flexible and user friendly software I ever used. Autodesk shall invest a bit, add those things from the wish list and it would became the leading software for structural engineers.

[mustafahesenow]

Hi @tom.krok

Many thanks for participating with us in this thread .

We love RSA and we want to be remained and keeped developed.

[mustafahesenow]

Autodesk keep developing the small things related to structural analysis in Revit. which is the most basic for engineering and forget the advantages and power of RSA .

[Iron.Max.Steel]

Yes, RSA is a very good software. I really surprise how does this happen. in RSA you can able to design and analysis almost all type of structures.

Unlike other software they are limited, for etabs can use for buildings only, sap2000 its hard to model structure, for staad its lack of bridge design and I dont like the meshing option on staad is not so easy to generate.

[Mohammed_Ata]

Please, Autodesk Robot team.

We are hundreds of thousands of expert engineers and users of RSA for different years of experience ! We don't have the chance to find a powerful software like RSA !

Why to do such mistake ! If done, i think it makes no trust in Autodesk! Every lots of year, a software to be cancelled ! 

In 2015, ASD has been stopped and many of engineers refer to Revit 2015, Robot 2015 to use the last version of ASD.

Now, 2018, you want to make this fault again! To make it as ladder for Revit ! 

Please, don't do it. We are using this powerful software and want to be improved. 

Forza RSA 

Mohammed Ata 

Structural design engineer. 

[teixeiranh]

It is really surprising knowing that Autodesk is going to let Robot.

Here in Portugal, at least in the north part of the country, every structural engineer uses Robot. Nobody uses SAP, or etabs, or staabs, or risa or whatever.

I have spent a big deal of time working with it. Every structure that I designed or helped design was designed with Robot.

I did, has some of you might know, a series of videos explaining how to use this beautiful piece of software.

Reading that Autodesk is going to let go is like watching all those hours spent on Camtasia go as well. It is heartbreaking for me.

I must say that the strategy followed should be making Robot better. To have the best of all tools to work with Revit.

Think about it! A revit structure user wants to use the software that has the best linking capacities with it. The best one should be Robot! Is autodesk really leating Risa, or Sap or whatever take that place?

Or is it a market problem? Does the Robot user represents a "small market"? Take a look at my channel, I have almost 2500 subscribers.

I think that it is a really bad idea. A stupid one. You should upgrade Robot. Make it better. Steal the SAP users with the arguments "YES, it is the best one to link with REVIT" and "Yes, it has the greatest computation capabilities".

Don't be dumb. Behind every beautiful architectural project is a smart structural engineer.

And (please!!) be realistic. Revit is never going to be a structural analysis software. It is too slow and has buttons related with MEP. Who the f*** cares about MEP buttons or architecture commands when you area dealing with load paths? Come on!