Solid-shell Idealization Model

Solid-shell Idealization Model

wasim_younis
Enthusiast Enthusiast
687 Views
2 Replies
Message 1 of 3

Solid-shell Idealization Model

wasim_younis
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

I have modelled a square plate (100x100x10) attached to another thin plate (100x100x2), with bonded contact. I then fix it at one end of the thick plate and apply a load on the other end of the thick plate. 

I then analyse the thin plate using shell idealization by selecting the face of the thick plate. I was hoping to get the same results as  shown below. Can you please advise

1.PNG2.PNG

0 Likes
688 Views
2 Replies
Replies (2)
Message 2 of 3

Anonymous
Not applicable

I am interested, which is the answer?

I have noted that the max stress is beyond the yield for the ABS material.

Can be that?

0 Likes
Message 3 of 3

John_Holtz
Autodesk Support
Autodesk Support

Hi @wasim_younis 

 

The solid-to-solid model is giving inaccurate results because the bonded contact is too stiff. See Model with bonded contact between thin parts behaving too stiff in simulation. When the bonded contact is replaced with offset bonded contact, the displacement in the Z direction is -1.33.

 

The solid-to-shell model is giving inaccurate results of -1.86 because the mid-height of the shell is not resting on top of the solid. The mid-height should be 1 mm higher than the mesh. If you edit the shell idealization > Advanced Options > Midplane Offset Distance = 1 mm, then the calculated displacement is -1.46.

 

So the solid model with the offset bonded contact (-1.33) and the shell model (-1.46) are giving similar results. The shell result should be more accurate because the shells calculate the bending in the steel more accurately. A finer mesh for the solid-to-solid should give a result closer to the shell model result.

 



John Holtz, P.E.

Global Product Support
Autodesk, Inc.


If not provided, indicate the version of Inventor Nastran you are using.
If the issue is related to a model, attach the model! See What files to provide when the model is needed.