Community
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Real Thread Modeled

Real Thread Modeled

Maybe there are already similar ideas..

 

But.

 

If you want a real modeled thread in Inventor what do you do?

 

1- you have to model it by yourself (sketch...coil/sweep, etc)  (db18cec69d42acd83a8a8fb084e50d4f

 

2- you have to use a third part app called "coolOrange threadModeler". ( We-think-Tired-yawning-surprised

 

 

 

But...why?emojipedia-colbert-emoji-sample

 

 

We (I) would like to see this!

 

dxdx.jpg

126 Comments
Anonymous
Not applicable

Thanks for the quick reply.

I am trying out the Coolorange thread modeler and it seems to be ok. I know there are plenty of ways to do this either through 3rd party extensions / plugins or services, but, I just cannot believe that this isn't a stock standard feature of Inventor, it really should be.

Anonymous
Not applicable

I agree!

Fusion 360 have modeled thread functionality by default on the box (without extension or plugins). Why Inventor still not have this?

 

To design plastic parts cast on molds, not enough thread symbols in the drawing, need geometry (surface) for the matrix.
 Not always, but often the design requires standard threads. EVERYTHING about THEM is KNOWN.

 

It is very strange...

 

These little things accumulate like an annoying poison in the engineer's heart, I'm disappointed.

Anonymous
Not applicable

The Apps "supporting" the lack of this feature doesn't work any more and/or have problems and/or we need to wait the 3rd parties to release them for the next version of Inventor. coolOrange has its own problems now. We cannot afford to rely upon a vendor which is small and focused elsewhere.

 

It is disappointing that Inventor doesn't have it today when the additive manufacturing is a huge market.

scottmoyse
Mentor

Fusion 360 does an incredible job of modelling threads... please just copy the 3D output from there.. I'm not certain on the UI side of things though. I think the Hole UI is better in Inventor... the thread UI should probably match that.

Anonymous
Not applicable

I agree,

in times when 3D printing ist a rising market, a funktion for real modelled threads is a must have for CAD-software.

stuartf
Contributor

We desperately need this for 3D printing. I have used the Cool orange plug in but it only works for basic threads and requires an awkward workflow for threading holes. Currently its easier to open the part in Fusion to add threads prior to printing.

christianW6BMB
Community Visitor

Agree that there should be an option to have modelled thread available; especially when it comes to 3D printing

a.grolleau
Participant

YESSS!!

and yes there is an app/plugin, there is only one. BUT I want it in the native software and with all the standarts (ISO, UNF, etc..) PLEASE!

In 2018, all industrials are using 3D printing, 3D CAD softwares MUST up to date. that all! We are talking about an about 2000€/year software not a free one. And it's possible beacause a free plug-in can do it.

 

But users seems to be happy with an half app/plug-in (not all the standarts), I don't think Autodesk will up a little finger to introduce it in the next release 😞

 

note : coolOrange - Thread modeler is a very good plug-in I didn't say the opposite. Good job!

Anonymous
Not applicable

CoolOrange thread modeler isn't working for me in Inventor 2019. Modeled thread functionality is desperately needed, we use it all the time for printed parts, but sending files to SW or F360 for threads is getting old. Plus the wide variety of profiles and ease of parameter adjustment for threads in SW make it very nice.HANDLE-NUT_REVA.jpg

steinar_sorem
Advocate

Autodesk, is 3D modeled thread option planned to be released in Inventor 2021? Due to 3D printing this is big missed feature.

 

BR

Steinar Sørem

CAD Adm

Kongsberg Maritime

jason.wells
Participant

The temptation to create 100 more accounts and vote for this again and again is real!

Thanks

PatrickCampbellCoral
Contributor

I just went thru the Coolorange add-in for a 1" NPT thread that I need, because I'm basically 3D printing ALL my parts now for fit check (and many of them are staying 3D printed and not CNC'd).

 

It's less than ideal, as I had to fill the existing NPT hole feature, extrude a new one that was tapered, add the thread feature, do the coolorange thing, then chop off the extra threads because my hole depth was only 15mm and the threads come in at 25.006mm. 

 

So now instead of 1 feature for an NPT hole, my tree has 7.  

 

This is a band-aid and not a legitimate solution. Please add this feature.

dusan.naus.trz
Advisor

My idea is different from this. I don't know who combined these ideas. When you look at my iLogic it is for drawing. This theme is for a model. Can anyone explain it to me? Why were ideas merged that have nothing in common?

jingyi.liu
Alumni

Hi @dusan.naus.trz 

Sorry for that, your idea on drawing template was merged to thread modeler by mistake. Let me check if we can fix the issue.

 

Jingyi

dusan.naus.trz
Advisor

@jingyi.liu 

Thanks for exploring.
To be precise, the ideas are from marthall. I only added comments and specified the procedure.
I have verified the function for version 2021. So far, the function is not available. The solution is iLogic code. That's enough for me. Just not all users know that it can be changed with this code.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3SMqikr6VEY

ethan_howardMMXXIV
Collaborator

Time-Saver/Productivity Idea/Inventor Stomps Competition - How much time do we spend on figuring out threads so we can 3D print a prototype part (rhetorical)? I currently have a non-standard/non-standard thread to model. Non-standard for Inventor but also non-standard for the industry: 1 5/8 - 16 BUTT-2A-RH. I need the mating 2B thread also.
Idea sequence after selecting Thread Button:
1.) Select the surface/face.
2.) Select the Thread TYPE, SIZE (auto-input from the surface/face), PITCH, CLASS & DIRECTION.
3.) Select Thread DEPTH & OFFSET.
4.) Select whether the thread is a simplified or modeled by clicking the correct CHECK BOX.

(Screen captures below & attached showing visual sequence and tool calculator)

Thread_Creator.JPG

Thread_Calculation.jpg

Even if I have a thread calculator tool, like ThreadPal, I still must model it.

Tags (3)

Just came here looking exactly for this.  I'm using 2021 and just needed a fully modeled thread for a 3D printed project.  No problem, I go and get the coolOrange Thread Modeler add-in from the store and install it.  Hmmm, doesn't work.  Turns out 2020 will be the last supported version.  We need the ability to have fully modeled/functional threads easily within Inventor.  At a bare minimum, please add the feature that is available in Fusion 360.  I ended up using Fusion to remodel my part with threads.

ethan_howardMMXXIV
Collaborator

@Daniel.SponholzQJA9W I'm glad I'm not the only one that thinks this would be a great advantage over other CAD modelers and a real boost in the right direction for 3D printing. This would put Inventor above the rest. If coolOrange can do it, then so can we.

ethan_howardMMXXIV
Collaborator

I've recently been working through the "Tutorial Gallery" and discovered the power of Inventor in "Design Accelerator" features, not to mention the "Frame Generator". Wow! Knowing this power, it makes me hope that there could be a Design Accelerator for all types of threads (Thread Modeler). The gear modeling is amazing so you're almost there!

Capture1.PNG

Anonymous
Not applicable

Hi.

 

Thread modeler from Cool Orange doesn't work in Inventor 2021. I would like to have some tool which will generate a real thread (3D thread). It would help a lot in usual design process, also in 3D-printing of part with the thread. Thank you 😃

Tags (4)

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea  

Autodesk Design & Make Report