EXTRUDE BUGGED WHEN USING "ALL"

[programming2C78B]

[johnsonshiue]

Hi! Is the target two separate parts or bodies? If you expand the "Objects to Cut" arrow button, what objects are selected? If possible, please share the f3d file here.

Many thanks!

[TheCADWhisperer]

@programming2C78B 

What do you see if you expand this?

[laughingcreek]

@johnsonshiue - this is extremely easy to reproduce.  there are 2 seperate bodies, but only one is available in the dialog when using extrude all-

but both are available if using other types, such as extrude to-

model attached.

[laughingcreek]

@johnsonshiue - even worse if you do the following-

-hide body 1

-extrude all, cutting into body 2

-show body 1

-edit the original extrude

you lose the reference to body 2 in the extrude feature for some reason.  see video- 

[programming2C78B]

Yes, I made sure the objects to cut showed both that's why I started with showing the Distance version before changing it to All. 

[TrippyLighting]

@Phil.E to the rescue 😉

[Phil.E]

@TrippyLighting Not much to rescue here. The extrude command fails to cut "all" when two bodies are the cut target. This could be a bug, or just a limitation. I'll let the modeling team know. (FUS-196517)

Meanwhile, to get the job done, if you want to do this without two extrudes, make it parametric. In this image, "width" controls both the vice jaws and the cut.

[programming2C78B]

more strange behavior

[TrippyLighting]

We need a model to to reproduce that behavior. 

[programming2C78B]

except people here have been able to replicate it themselves on their end without knowing any of my model or sizes? 

[TrippyLighting]

Ok. Suit yourself!

[Phil.E]

I apologize, but I have no idea what that image is showing. Can you please elaborate a little and that might help me understand how to replicate the issue and log a ticket for it?

[programming2C78B]

@trippy these are customer models and I cant share them willy nilly online

@Phil.E I am extruding a dovetail from the centerline of a cylinder. The arrow is pointing to how its not cutting that one segment for some reason. 
I restarted and now it works. 

[Phil.E]

Good to know. If you find anything like this that you can share, including just an image or video, or a model, with steps I can follow, I will always bring any bugs I find to the developers. Thanks for posting and helping.