Changing Sketch Dimension Causes Bend Problems

xrotaryguy8TL48
Explorer
Explorer

Changing Sketch Dimension Causes Bend Problems

xrotaryguy8TL48
Explorer
Explorer

I changed the location of a couple holes in my sketch. This caused Bend1 to stop working. I tried several things, making sure lines were connected etc but was unable to get the bend to work again. I finally deleted the bend in the timeline and started over. Now when I attempt a new bend, I am able to select the stationary side but selecting any bend line causes an error:

 

"Stationary side is lost. Most likely due to a geometry change. This will require reselecting stationary face and all bend lines." 

 

I'm new to Fusion. I have a lot more experience with SolidWorks and (due to a frugal employer back in the day) Sketchup. I'm guessing there's some common mistake I'm making. I have attached the file. 

 

TIA!!! 

 

 

0 Likes
Reply
Accepted solutions (1)
325 Views
5 Replies
Replies (5)

javelin_exile
Advocate
Advocate
Accepted solution

Put your bend lines on a sketch by themselves and try it. I created a new sketch, projected your 2 beld lines on it and used those in the selection. make your sketches black too  

1 Like

xrotaryguy8TL48
Explorer
Explorer

That worked. The holes in the flange didn't come along for the ride unfortunately. Is it common that I should need to put the holes in the flange after the bend to avoid this in the future? 

0 Likes

javelin_exile
Advocate
Advocate

if you look at your sketch there was an extra line segment duplicated on the perimeter. that seems to be what was causing it. I must have deleted it without pointing that out so I went back and looked again.

 

The better you make the sketches the less trouble you will have later is what I've found. always make them black and der rid of white dots and extra line. Sometimes if i've overworked a sketch I'll  make a new one with projected geometry so I can pick what needs to be in there. less is better and rely more on constraints than dimensions.  

1 Like

xrotaryguy8TL48
Explorer
Explorer

Agreed. This sketch was messy. It was imported from Sketchup as a DXF and there were definitely imperfections.

 

I see now that making the sketch black is the same as "fully constrained" in Solidworks. Got it. Thanks!! 

0 Likes

javelin_exile
Advocate
Advocate

yes exactly, except there isn't a helpful fully define button

0 Likes