Announcements

Welcome to Forma for Construction Ideas! View the Forma for Construction Product Roadmap here. Top-voted ideas may be considered for future development. Learn more about the feedback process here.

cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Model Coordination > Clashes

Model Coordination > Clashes

Idea:

Option to revert clash data to clashes list in case of miss selection of clash item on created issue by actually voiding/deleting issue item 

 

Current behavior:

when Issue item is deleted, the clash data will not go back to the clashes list instead it will go with the deleted issue

 

Model Coordination Idea.jpg

6 Comments
thomas_seufert
Participant

It would be helpful if you could also view deleted collisions in a matrix. Perhaps in different colours (e.g. blue and magenta) to distinguish them from the actual collision list. This would make it possible to understand / check whether the deletion of the collision is correct.  A filter option by user, date and reason for deletion would also helpfully.

thomas_seufert
Participant

It would be helpful if you could also view deleted collisions in a matrix. Perhaps in different colours (e.g. blue and magenta) to distinguish them from the actual collision list. This would make it possible to understand / check whether the deletion of the collision is correct. A filter option by user, date and reason for deletion would also help.

hmonteiroXGRQW
Explorer

I am looking for a document that shows how the re-clashing happens and even if I delete an issue will it come back if I haven't specifically flagged it as not an issue. Then I can delete the issue and it would have to come back as a clash. Not being able to organize clashes in any way let alone similar to Navisworks is really slowing down the process of coordinating. 

dan_hinesNEVNS
Explorer

Something that I have found to be problematic on several projects is that clashes understandably leave the clash pool upon being assigned to an issue. This behaviour is fine and logical until a project member goes full tilt creating issues from clashes, or you realise just after creating the issue that something was incorrectly included/excluded. In these cases depending on how widespread the impact is the only real workaround is to set up a whole new coordination space or reuploading the affected models-both being unideal solutions.

 

What would be greatly helpful is to basically have an option where by in these situations the issue can be deleted/deactivated and all those clashes return back to the clash pool for future review. As it stands, when clashes are marked as 'not an issue' we have the option to restore the clashes to the pool. It seems logical to have this exact same functionality for clashes that incorrectly or prematurely get assigned to an issue.

Susana_Duarte_LMSI
Collaborator

Even though this idea was first, I would propose to merge with this one: Model Coordination > Clashes - Autodesk Community

@kimberly_fuhrman-jones , do you agree?

dan_hinesNEVNS
Explorer

yep i agree should be merged. Just glad I am not the only one who wishes this worked differently

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea