Why can't ACAD import STL format while can export it? It's very common and should be one of the simplest formats ACAD can import.
The answer I found here is quite unsatisfactory.
https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/autocad-forum/stl-import/m-p/7743152#M918224
Does someone know any "real" reasons?
Solved! Go to Solution.
Solved by BeKirra. Go to Solution.
Hi,
>> The answer I found here is quite unsatisfactory.
But it's the truth.
You can always find programs which don't support one or other fileformat.
And STL is mainly an export format to send geometry in a simply way to the printer. But importing back an STL does not recognize any geometry primitves like sphere, cylinder, box, ... Having said that it is close to uneditable. It's like a one-way format ... explode all to make it simple meshes, but getting back exploded objects to make them editable is complex or unavailable.
But you always have the chance to add a comment to the product team >>>there<<<.
- alfred -
Hi,
If you want to edit .stl files I would suggest you use the following Autodesk freeware called Meshmixer.
Other than that I have nothing to add to what was already said by @Alfred.NESWADBA
It is not clear if you want to actually import an stl file into AutoCAD or just want to know why a direct importer is not part of AutoCAD. I cannot help you with the latter question but if you have an stl file and want to make an AutoCAD solid model from it then one way is to import the stl file into 3ds Max and then export from Max to the .dwg format. You can then open the dwg file in AutoCAD and use SURFSCULPT to make the tessellated file into a solid.
I am afraid users here cannot answer your question but the AutoCAD development team from Autodesk.
IMO you may also submit an idea to this forum:
https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/product-design-suite-ideas/idb-p/102/tab/most-recent
Unfortunately there is no "AutoCAD Ideas" forum available.
In the meanwhile, you may consider what Lee has suggested, or open your STL file with Inventor then export it to STP format.
HTH
I am afraid users here cannot answer your question but the AutoCAD development team from Autodesk.
I think this is the most reasonable answer. Thank you!
The problem with Meshmixer is that all the formats that it can export are formats that cannot be imported into Autocad. A lot of people seem to assume that we all have 3DS Max, Inventor or some other multi-thousand dollar program. If Autodesk has all this code, why not let us get add-ons or just pick it from the menu?
Can you import an .stl file into AutoCAD? This question is now a few years old. The accepted answer was. "It cant be done, speak to the development team". Several years later and advances in new software has brought us closer to an acceptable solution.
1. Import Stl file into MeshLabs
2. Export to XYZ point cloud
3. Import Point Cloud into ReCap Pro
4. Export to RCP file
5. Xref import the RCP file into AutoCAD.
*Disclaimers. An stl file is a mesh which means that AutoCAD is not the best software to modify it. Fusion360 is a better place to work with it. The method above makes the stl file appear in AutoCAD in a way that the software can handle it. You can't modify it but you can use it to trace over features in creating a new AutoCad drawing or model. The image attached is of a 3d scan, imported into AutoCAD.
The STL format is pretty well defined. I wrote some "C" code (ARX program) to import and export STL files, binary and ASCII, for R14 almost 20 years ago. The STL triangles are imported as 3DFACE's.
I have found the MeshIn freeware for this. Works fine, imports not only STL but even for OBJ and 3DS files, but it is quite slow on larger STLs.
https://www.cadforum.cz/en/how-to-import-an-stl-obj-or-3ds-file-to-an-autocad-3d-model-tip14072
Just out of curiosity, how slow is quite slow? I have a binary STL file that has 1,008,964 triangles and it takes me 130 seconds to load it, but I am using 32 bit R14.
Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.