Error 2110 - problem with linear loads?

[Anonymous]

I have been applying wind loads and cladding loads in Robot. Originally I had applied these as linear load on edges but when transferring between robot to Revit found the loads were not recognised. 

I then proceeded to delete these loads and reapply them using the linear load 2p type. These have been transferred between robot and revit however now when running the analysis I get an error 2110 and no results. When clicking on the error in the relevant load case I can see it highlights all the reapplied loads that I entered using linear load 2p. 

PLease can you help correct my model so the loads can be applied. There are lots of loads added this way so a method that can correct them all collectively would be ideal. I also want the model to be able to be transferred between robot and revit. 

I did try and upload the file but it is too large and it wont let me do it - 20mb big. 

Your help would be much appreciated.

Regards

Eddy Battman

[Rafacascudo]

Save it under a new name and without results. Zip it . If it is still too large ,

http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/robot-structural-analysis/sending-bigger-files/td-p/3795062

[Rafal.Gaweda]

Eddy

run this macro:

http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/robot-structural-analysis/generation-of-calculation-model-takes-foreve...

to convert loads. If you are using v 2015 or 2016 the trick from video is not needed, I guess.

Then calculate the file.

If it does not help please send us the file in the way Rafacascudo suggested.

[Anonymous]

Here is the file. Zip makes it much smaller. 

It seems the quantity of the linear 2p loads is triggering the error 2110. Why is this so. The more streamlined solution applying loads to slab edge is what I usually use but this does not transfer between revet and robot. 

Another person said to use a macro to change them to slab edge loads. But the link sent me to a website that just downloaded junk. 

Can you help?

[Rafal.Gaweda · Accepted solution]

1. Use attached macro to help converting loads (convert cases 1 4 5 6 7)

2. Turn off kinematic links in job preferences

3. mesh correctly model

4. calculate structure -> no error 2110 but you will see that some linear loads are not applied warning

to find them

5. use this addin: http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/robot-structural-analysis/linear-load-has-not-been-applied-to-the-pane...

6. calculate model and find all cases with sums of reactions = zeros

7. because new case = one load record on one object (for eg line) it is easy to find all errorneus lines

8. delete them or correct their locations

File with converted loads (steps1to4 made): http://we.tl/2bH7HYCueQ 

Take a look at lines  562 563 589 568  571 572 720  - correct them or delete them

[Rafal.Gaweda]

Update to macro: macro works on multiple cases list

[MarkNguyen...]

Hi @Rafal.Gaweda, i tried your macro convert linear load to lne load. It is quite useful.But is not automatically assigned to load records. Do you fix this bug ?  It would be great if it automatically assigns the load records.

[Rafal.Gaweda]

Hi @MarkNguyen...

It does work:

[MarkNguyen...]

hi @Rafal.Gaweda , I tried again but it doesn't work as i expect. You can see :

https://autode.sk/2s1LZWX

[MarkNguyen...]

Hi @Rafal.Gaweda Did you see my screencast above ? i hope you can solve this issue. Thanks for your support.

[Rafal.Gaweda]

Hi @MarkNguyen...

Seems to be a bug in API.

I will report it.

Thanks.

[MarkNguyen...]

I look forward to you @Rafal.Gaweda

[MarkNguyen...]

Hi  @Rafal.Gaweda Did you fix this bug?

[Rafal.Gaweda]

Hi @MarkNguyen...

This issue is in Robot API , not in my code.

[MarkNguyen...]

@Rafal.Gaweda thank for your respond. I look forward to fix this bug.