Retaining Walls - Provided Reinforcement & Workflow

Retaining Walls - Provided Reinforcement & Workflow

Lor_UK_IT
Participant Participant
491件の閲覧回数
10件の返信
メッセージ1/11

Retaining Walls - Provided Reinforcement & Workflow

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

Hi Everyone 😊

I’m writing to ask some help to the more experienced Robot users.

I’m designing a basement level (or a pool if you like), with 4 walls (retaining walls)
bearing onto a slab (raft foundation).

I’ve realised, after using Robot a bit, that the “Wall” command is not the right tool
(if used in these circumstances) as it doesn’t take in consideration any force out of the plane.

In the screenshot below you can see 5 “Floors” which are all “Shell”.
The raft foundation has got an “Elastic” support and is fixed to all the walls with a fixed support

(not sure if this is correct).

There are several loads applied on the structure (the screenshots shows just the soil pressure).

 

Lor_UK_IT_0-1722345266465.png

Structure with deformation enabled

 

Lor_UK_IT_1-1722345352614.png

Provided reinforcement for one of the walls, the corners

don't have any reinforcement at all and just straight bars are provided.

 

Lor_UK_IT_2-1722345448022.png

Provided reinforcement for the fixed support (retaining walls)

 

What I would like to ask, is the below:

  1. Is this the right way to Design retaining walls in Robot?
  2. How comes that doesn’t matter what loads you apply, the provided reinforcement is ALWAYS shape “00”, which is a straight bar in the British Code?
    Is this a software limitation given by Robot which thinks that is a floor and not a wall?
    Am I doing something wrong?

Any advice or correction on my approach would be greatly appreciated.

Kind Regards,
Lorenzo

0 件のいいね
492件の閲覧回数
10件の返信
返信 (10)
メッセージ2/11

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

Any help from anyone?

0 件のいいね
メッセージ3/11

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

???

0 件のいいね
メッセージ4/11

Simau
Mentor
Mentor

Hi @Lor_UK_IT 

Zip and share your model

M. Agayr
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

0 件のいいね
メッセージ5/11

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

Hi @Simau ,

Please find attached a very similar project (identical, just difference shape).

 

Many Thanks in advance!!!

0 件のいいね
メッセージ6/11

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

@Simaufor some reason it doesn't allow me to upload the file, please download it from here:
https://we.tl/t-PZ2B3rzOqq

0 件のいいね
メッセージ7/11

umut.akparlar
Collaborator
Collaborator

Hi @Lor_UK_IT 

 

Are you designing your wall based on BS-EN right?

 

There is no provided reinforcement module for BS-EN (or EN) in Robot. As far as I know, you can only get required reinforcement in BS-EN (EC2) for RC wall design.

 

May I ask how did you get 3D rebar detailing based on British code? 

 

Btw, you need to zip your file before uploading it to the forum.

 

Thanks

0 件のいいね
メッセージ8/11

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

These are my job preferences:

Loads:

Lor_UK_IT_0-1727102607631.png

Reinforcing bars:

Lor_UK_IT_1-1727102641696.png

 

0 件のいいね
メッセージ9/11

Lor_UK_IT
Participant
Participant

@Simau 

File attached

0 件のいいね
メッセージ10/11

umut.akparlar
Collaborator
Collaborator

Hi @Lor_UK_IT 

 

How about design codes? 

 

umutakparlar_0-1727102991292.png

 

You shared only load combination codes not design codes. 

 

Thanks 

0 件のいいね
メッセージ11/11

Simau
Mentor
Mentor

@Lor_UK_IT 

This is not really the same kind of model.
Please share your first model or tell us your problem with this one.

M. Agayr
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

0 件のいいね