Different ratios for member and group verification

[ewu168]

Hi Artur,

In this pylon model, pls help to looking into following problems:

1. In the first screenshot, what shall I specify the "Load Type" for the wind load..."Uniform" or "(FE) Uniform"? what is the difference?
2. In the second screenshot, I'm getting "Section error" in "Member verification", while "Section OK" in "Group Verification"...why Robot gives out different result?

Pls find the Robot file as attached, 

Regards

Eric

@ewu168 Artur Kosakowski edited the topic for better findability 

[Artur.Kosakowski · Accepted solution]

Hi Eric,

1. In the first screenshot, what shall I specify the "Load Type" for the wind load..."Uniform" or "(FE) Uniform"? what is the difference?

The prior is the bar type load whereas the later applies to surfaces

2. In the second screenshot, I'm getting "Section error" in "Member verification", while "Section OK" in "Group Verification"...why Robot gives out different result?

The prior was launched for both ULS and SLS and failed for serviceability whereas the later for ULS only.

If you find your post answered press the Accept as Solution button please. This will help other users to find solutions much faster. Thank you.

[ewu168]

Thank you Artur, I got it now 🙂

Regards

Eric