Revit Structure Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Revit Structure Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular Revit Structure topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

RVT22-Column &Beams transfer between RVT & AdvanceSteel

4 REPLIES 4
SOLVED
Reply
Message 1 of 5
AntDrt
789 Views, 4 Replies

RVT22-Column &Beams transfer between RVT & AdvanceSteel

Hello everyone,

got a issue with the link between RVT2022 & AdvanceSteel 2022

i'll use these terms :

> FF (fabrication form) : steel element ( column or beams) with steel element applied to them ( connection / weld / bolts)

> CF (classical form) : native steel element (no connections applied to them)

 

there my issues:

> Column orientation  : 

   For CF element when i export from RVT to AS, profiles are rotated to 90° in AS 

   for FF elements, good orientation in AS

See below:

Columns in revitColumns in revitColumn in ASColumn in AS

 

> Beam with offset:

   for CF element, when i export from RVT to AS, offset are in wrong value (ex: -20 is set to +20)

   for FF elements, good offset set in AS

See below:

RVT beamsRVT beamsAS beamsAS beams

 

Orientation & offset seems to be related to the fabrication form.

Does anyone can reproduce this issue on his side ?

 

i attach the RVT22 model / the AS22 model / the .SMLX file

Antoine
AMG Fechoz
Serrurerie & Equipement Scénographique
www.amg-fechoz.com
4 REPLIES 4
Message 2 of 5
AntDrt
in reply to: AntDrt

update: 2021/04/21

got a feedback on AS forum, and before installing 2022 version, 2021 exports well, but after installation of 2022 version 2021 export seems buggy now.

got a feedback only on orientation problem, not offset currently.

Antoine
AMG Fechoz
Serrurerie & Equipement Scénographique
www.amg-fechoz.com
Message 3 of 5
AntDrt
in reply to: AntDrt

hi again, 

update from AutodeskSupport:

Columns with user section are rotated 90 or 180 degree in Advance Steel after import them from Revit...

 

but it isn't related to my problem, it is not user sections and i've tried with US AISC 14.1 U sections from the "load autodesk family" function in revit.

 

And problem is still present. see below:

default US Based family Revitdefault US Based family RevitUS family ASUS family AS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

it has to be fixed ASAP, and from AS forum it seems to corrupt previous version (20/21..)

Antoine
AMG Fechoz
Serrurerie & Equipement Scénographique
www.amg-fechoz.com
Message 4 of 5
AntDrt
in reply to: AntDrt

update 2021-04-30

After reinstalling Microsoft Acess Database Engine 2010, problem seems to have diseappear. 

Antoine
AMG Fechoz
Serrurerie & Equipement Scénographique
www.amg-fechoz.com
Message 5 of 5
mihai.sandu
in reply to: AntDrt

Created an AKN article from this issue:
https://knowledge.autodesk.com/community/article/357262



Mihai Sandu

Sr. QA Analyst

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Forma Design Contest


Autodesk Design & Make Report