Revit MEP Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Revit MEP Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular Revit MEP topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Control which Leg gets 0 load

6 REPLIES 6
SOLVED
Reply
Message 1 of 7
dtiemeyer
189 Views, 6 Replies

Control which Leg gets 0 load

My engineer showed me a 240v 3 phase panelboard which uses 3 pole breakers but one of the legs (always the center B leg) is 0 load, and the load is distributed always across A-C legs. How can I control the legs that a load lands on in this case. In trying to modify the single-phase subpanel to control this, I realize I do not know a way to separate the load of what is being powered from what it looks like being powered by an upstream panel; essentially I want to take all 3 legs of connected load and distribute them to 2 legs outgoing.  Currently the only way I see to get the loads on the desired legs A-C, is to move the breaker up or down in the panelboard, which is undesirable. 

My other CAD is a Cadillac and I like to Revit to the Max!
Labels (2)
6 REPLIES 6
Message 2 of 7
HVAC-Novice
in reply to: dtiemeyer

I assume B-leg to be unused was chosen by Revit when balancing the load. If you add other loads to A, or C, and re-balance, it might jump tp use B. 

 

What type of system is it? Is it 240V between legs, or from leg to neutral? Do you mean the European 230/400V system? What device would only use 2 phases? Why a single phase panel with a family that seems to use 3 poles? Why a 3-pole breaker on a 2-pole device? 

 

Revit version: R2025.4
Message 3 of 7
dtiemeyer
in reply to: dtiemeyer

@HVAC-Novice Please see responses from my engineer:

 

What type of system is it?  240V 3-Phase High Leg Delta

Is it 240V between legs, or from leg to neutral? This is fun, 3-Phase High Leg has a 240 leg to leg. The A leg and the C leg are 120 V from leg to neutral, the B leg is 208V from leg to neutral.

Do you mean the European 230/400V system? No, see above.

What device would only use 2 phases? The distribution panelboard feeding the panel we are working on is 1 Phase (2 legs) 240/120V. To not have the B leg going to the panelboard, this would create a 208V leg to neutral which is not something most equipment is rated for, a three-pole breaker is connected to the panelboard because the buss goes A>B>C>A>B>C… as you go down the circuits on a panelboard. This means that to get only the A and C phases, you would have to pick a specific breaker number like 5,7 to get a situation where it is C>A between two poles in sequence.  

Why a single-phase panel with a family that seems to use 3 poles? Answered above

Why a 3-pole breaker on a 2-pole device? To avoid the B leg, a three-pole breaker is attached but no conductors are connected to the B leg only the A and C, neutral and ground.  

My other CAD is a Cadillac and I like to Revit to the Max!
Message 4 of 7
sragan
in reply to: dtiemeyer

Revit 2025 has the ability to model high leg systems, which wasn't available in previous systems.

 

But I still assume you probably have to move the breakers around to get them on the right phases.   Or maybe you could assign "Space" to all the B phases before circuiting loads.  Then they will be forced to use A and C.

 

Message 5 of 7
HVAC-Novice
in reply to: dtiemeyer

I have nothing further to contribute, but this explanation of high-delta may be useful.

Revit version: R2025.4
Message 6 of 7
dtiemeyer
in reply to: dtiemeyer

@sragan thanks for pointing this out, I hadn't noticed that yet, since we haven't started on a project in 2025 yet, the project for this question is in 2024. Cheers. And thanks @HVAC-Novice for digging deeper with the questions and engaging the convo to get us to the answer.

My other CAD is a Cadillac and I like to Revit to the Max!
Message 7 of 7
sragan
in reply to: dtiemeyer

See attached for the Revit 2025 Distribution settings, with the high leg options.

 

High Leg Distribution.jpg

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Autodesk Design & Make Report