When joining 2 roofs of same material together, the line of the roofs does not disappear. Please Help

[sshamby]

I have a project where I know the low side of my roof truss, but do not know the high side. The high side will vary quite a bit across the building so to get around having to modify sub elements I created two roofs, one with a slope, and one that is flat. The flat roof sits inside the sloped roof. When I try to join the two roofs together, the lines do not disappear, even though the layers being joined are the same material. I have attached picture for reference. Typically when I join other elements with the same material together the line disappears, but in this instance it does not. I have attached some image for context

Two roofs not joined

Two roofs joined

 

[sshamby]

I have a project where I know the low side of my roof truss, but do not know the high side. The high side will vary quite a bit across the building so to get around having to modify sub elements I created two roofs, one with a slope, and one that is flat. The flat roof sits inside the sloped roof. When I try to join the two roofs together, the lines do not disappear, even though the layers being joined are the same material. I have attached picture for reference. Typically when I join other elements with the same material together the line disappears, but in this instance it does not. I have attached some image for context

Two roofs not joined

Two roofs joined

 

[barthbradley]

Almost sounds like you are describing a parapet wall the attaches to a sloped base. If so, use the Attach Top/Base Tool and check the "Base" radio button on the Option Bar.  

[barthbradley]

Almost sounds like you are describing a parapet wall the attaches to a sloped base. If so, use the Attach Top/Base Tool and check the "Base" radio button on the Option Bar.  

[sshamby]

No, Im just trying to get the line of the two roofs to go away when I join them. If im pulling a section i want to see the two roofs as if they were one, instead of seeing a line running through the middle of the two. 

[sshamby]

No, Im just trying to get the line of the two roofs to go away when I join them. If im pulling a section i want to see the two roofs as if they were one, instead of seeing a line running through the middle of the two. 

[barthbradley]

Overlap and use Join Geometry. Join Geometry will remove volume and linework at the union.  

[barthbradley]

Overlap and use Join Geometry. Join Geometry will remove volume and linework at the union.  

[sshamby]

Ok, so thats my problem, I did use join geometry, and those are the results I got, when I change the join order, the layers disappear altogether.

Here is a screencast of the issue

https://screencast.autodesk.com/Embed/Timeline/18d39149-dd88-49c4-81aa-c9883b81a23f

[sshamby]

Ok, so thats my problem, I did use join geometry, and those are the results I got, when I change the join order, the layers disappear altogether.

Here is a screencast of the issue

https://screencast.autodesk.com/Embed/Timeline/18d39149-dd88-49c4-81aa-c9883b81a23f

[ToanDN]

Share your model or at least the model of the two roofs.

[ToanDN]

Share your model or at least the model of the two roofs.

[sshamby]

Did you look at the video?

[sshamby]

Did you look at the video?

[ToanDN]

---

@sshamby wrote:

Did you look at the video?

---

It's not that hard to understand your question even without the video.  But yes I did watch it.

[ToanDN]

---

@sshamby wrote:

Did you look at the video?

---

It's not that hard to understand your question even without the video.  But yes I did watch it.

[sshamby]

Oh ok, so no idea's then?

[sshamby]

Oh ok, so no idea's then?

[ToanDN]

---

@sshamby wrote:

Oh ok, so no idea's then?

---

Might have one if you can share the model.  Or might not.

[ToanDN]

---

@sshamby wrote:

Oh ok, so no idea's then?

---

Might have one if you can share the model.  Or might not.

[sshamby]

Oh I gotcha, unfortunately this is a project for work and they wont let me export any revit models 😕

[sshamby]

Oh I gotcha, unfortunately this is a project for work and they wont let me export any revit models 😕

[Lachlan-JWP]

Uncheck "Common Edges" under the Roof category in the Visibility/Graphic Overrides for the view.

[Lachlan-JWP]

Uncheck "Common Edges" under the Roof category in the Visibility/Graphic Overrides for the view.

[sshamby]

Unfortunately that did not work either 😕

 

[sshamby]

Unfortunately that did not work either 😕

 

[Lachlan-JWP]

Can you delete all the irrelevant elements from the model and upload it for us to look at?

[Lachlan-JWP]

Can you delete all the irrelevant elements from the model and upload it for us to look at?

[sshamby]

Sure, I was able to create the same condition in a brand new project with a generic architectural template. I created two roofs, both same materials. both same phasing, except one has a 1/4" slope and the other is flat. I used the "join geometry" command to join the roofs together, but a line still shows up in section. 

[sshamby]

Sure, I was able to create the same condition in a brand new project with a generic architectural template. I created two roofs, both same materials. both same phasing, except one has a 1/4" slope and the other is flat. I used the "join geometry" command to join the roofs together, but a line still shows up in section. 

[Lachlan-JWP]

So it seems that when the base of one roof is entirely within another when you join them, then it will lose it's cut pattern. I wonder if @ToanDN or @barthbradley  know why that happens?

In the mean time you can use 1 roof with a variable layer and shape edit to achieve the same thing. See attached.

[Lachlan-JWP]

So it seems that when the base of one roof is entirely within another when you join them, then it will lose it's cut pattern. I wonder if @ToanDN or @barthbradley  know why that happens?

In the mean time you can use 1 roof with a variable layer and shape edit to achieve the same thing. See attached.

[ToanDN]

If you cannot use one roof with edited sub-elements then offset the footprint at one end of the sloped roof outboard slightly the flat roof @Lachlan-JWP mentioned.  Below are two roofs joined together.

[ToanDN]

If you cannot use one roof with edited sub-elements then offset the footprint at one end of the sloped roof outboard slightly the flat roof @Lachlan-JWP mentioned.  Below are two roofs joined together.