STAIRS PROBLEM

[basma_salman]

hello,

I am trying to create single step, but it is showing like in img below, it is extending beyond the tread,
I tried to change the connection method, the presentation is not correct

[barthbradley]

This is the booger that I (and the OP) are talking about.  What do you think?  Can you remove without converting to Sketch-Based?  School me.  

[MostafaElashmawy]

I tried but no luck.

[MostafaElashmawy · Accepted solution]

I could remove it only with changing the tread depth to 200mm instead of 300mm.

[barthbradley]

Nice spike.  Well done.  

[RDAOU]

I haven't modeled a stair since I think 3-4 year … I do not remember they were that complicated or that ugly lol

45 replies on 2 steps and still more solutions coming! I gotta grab something to drink and read through all 3 pages!

[barthbradley]

LOL!  Knock it off @RDAOU; some of us here are still nursing a hang-over.  

[basma_salman]

I removed it with the cut profile tool from the view tab, and this is only a 2d modification

[basma_salman]

interesting, I did not go through the notch settings before, I will check it, thank you @MostafaElashmawy 

[barthbradley]

---

@basma_salman wrote:

I removed it with the cut profile tool from the view tab, and this is only a 2d modification

---

What do you mean?  You don't need to cut geometry.  @MostafaElashmawy gave the solution. I tested it. It was ridiculously simple. I'm embarrassed, @RDAOU is laughing and@ToanDN, I think, went home early to see if there was any leftover champagne to drink. 

[basma_salman]

this what happens when I make depth 200

[basma_salman]

oh, I first have to change the straight cut into notch and then change the depth to 200
it is working perfectly thank u everyone 

[barthbradley]

BINGO!!!

[barthbradley]

I hate losing!!! But this was a fun tread.  Thanks @MostafaElashmawy .   Next time though; you're mine! Promise. 😉

[MostafaElashmawy]

@barthbradley I can't challenge you.

People like @ToanDN , you and @RDAOU  are like legends for me.

I learned alot from your previous solutions. 

I'm just trying to take a small part of the cake.

[barthbradley]

@basma_salman: Why @ToanDN  and not me for a Solution Credit?  I brought just as much value. Convert to Sketch is definitely a valid approach as I proved.  C'mon.  

[barthbradley]

@MostafaElashmawy: You're on my short of favorites -- right up there with @ToanDN and @RDAOU.  Let's just compete for those 'lil green checkmarks AND have a good time doing it together.   

[RDAOU]

@MostafaElashmawyflattering comment lol..you are quite good at it too helping and providing solutions...but sometime u do spam 3-4 replies in a row which makes me wonder if there is a race going on

@barthbradleyno competition here 🙂you are the boss … I definitely prefer giving someone the solution or workflow I follow instead of wasting my time get the Stair tool to behave the way they want just because they insist on using it and that will get me a green tick. That being said, the smartest reply I've read in those 3 pages was that given by @martijn_pater ...I do not believe I have ever heard of anyone modeling a 1 step using the stair tool!!!

I can imagine somone new having issues with stairs, comes to this forum, bumps into a post 4 pages long and in the end the conclusion of it is "Crack your head with the Stair tool" lol ... Hell NO!... you need 1 step to go from slab 1 to slab 2? simple, make that step part of slab 2!!! Need to cut the part of the stair inside walls slabs and other element? why not convert it to a geometry?

[martijn_pater]

@RDAOU  🙂 I would argue it's a valid approach 🙂 1 step will likely be some sort of (prefab?) block step... I guess…? or cast-in-place, but works anyway...

ps. Anyone else feeling the urge to quote Neil Armstrong here? lol

[RDAOU]

@martijn_pater  nothing there to be argued even if you disagree that the best approach is the practical one

[basma_salman]

i'm really sorry for that, all of u have helped a lot, solution credit right away for u!!! @barthbradley 😁
i'm just not concentrating because i'm busy working and trying to find solutions for my problem