cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Thread - External thread in Welded assembly

Thread - External thread in Welded assembly

Hello,

I would like to have thread feature in the assembly environment. 

Thanks

Dan

117 Comments
dan_butler_komatsu
Enthusiast
We went to a Gunslinger event in Novi about 2 weeks ago and asked them specifically about this enhancement because of the many comments of people who need this feature. You could tell it was well known to them that this is needed in Inventor. They just said that they are definitely working on it but I did not really ask for a specific event. I just remember them showing all the changes coming up and each one they showed was a user request from the Idea station. They literally are working constantly on our ideas and they ask us what we think of things they are working on. It is a matter of priority and resources that is why they have the kudos. This idea is needed and it is on the way. Fortunately, they can release these kinds of things in incremental released now instead of waiting for the main releases. I hope they will get this out very soon too. I saw various ideas that were submitted and are coming in some future releases. They are committed to listening to us and meeting our needs. It may not appear that way when we look at a specific feature like this one, but when you see the bigger picture of what they are doing it is really impressive.
gusi_cl
Advocate
Finally....a lot of users need this feature!!!


dwweekly
Advocate
LOL! This is hilarious , they finally get around to this in 5 years.

When will they add "named views" or "drill sizes"  in 2022? LOL
scottmoyse
Mentor
@Anonymous thanks for sharing that about the gunslinger. The other way to see how impressive their work is in relation to the ideastation, and how engaged they are with user feedback on new features they are developing is to join the beta. It's truly awesome.

The problem with this idea, it exposes an overall weakness of the assembly environment with respect to features. So it's clearly not an easy thing for them to implement. Glad it's on the way though!
Anonymous
Not applicable

Hi, I use Inventor 2018, but I can't find this still.

Why??

Thanks

karthur1
Mentor

Hi, I use Inventor 2018, but I can't find this still.  Why??

 

Why??? Because it is not implemented yet.  Doesn't look like it will ever be added either. They had rather put resources toward redoing the UI of commands that work just fine.

dan_butler_komatsu
Enthusiast
I recently attended a Gunslinger event in Novi Michigan with the Inventor developers. They had an all-day update for us of the changes that were being implemented for release 18 and beyond. On each of the screens they showed was a snapshot of the idea from the idea station. In other words, it seemed to me that about everything they are doing is from our ideas. I specifically asked about the threads in welded assemblies, and they said that it was in progress, the "story" line was being created. I also learned on several occasions from attended these events that simple changes to us have lots of complications on their part. And just like the rest of us they have limited resources and many challenges as well. They are implementing many things. I am sure the change will be here. The good news is that we don't have to wait for yearly releases.
iUser
Advocate

@dan_butler_komatsu : The problem is that they do not use the software on a daily basis (9 hours +) in the manufacturing / designing field. I have a work around for this welding in machining environment, but it is very time consuming. You can also see the OP posted this idea in 2012, almost 6 years down the line and we are still waiting for it.

 

On another note did you see any dual monitor improvements? Im refering to your one comment: "On each of the screens they showed was a snapshot of the idea from the idea station"..

Been waiting for that since 2013 (my original idea post date).

SofiaGrave4819
Enthusiast

HOw come that after so many years, Inventor still doesn't have external thread in weldments.

this is a major feature in some type of constructions.

please review again. this is very common process the the machinary industry.

 

Sofia Grave

karthur1
Mentor

This is an "Accepted" idea, so hopefully this will be in Inventor in the very near future. Keep your fingers crossed.

dan_szymanski
Autodesk

@jletcher @Dan_Margulius, @gusi_cl, @Anonymous, @Anonymous, @kstate92, @Anonymous, @Anonymous, @JonathanMLanderos, @manfredwinter3743, @Anonymous, @BCrosby, @Anonymous, @Anonymous, @JamesLodge01, @dwweekly, @iUser, @Anonymous, @scottmoyse, @Anonymous

 

Some possible solutions for this idea are currently under discussion on the NDA based Inventor Feedback/Beta forums. If you would like to contribute/validate then please apply for access using this link:   https://bit.ly/InventorBeta

 

Thanks, Dan

dan_szymanski
Autodesk

@Anonymous, @Anonymous, @DRoam, @bleeftink, @Anonymous, @Anonymous, @Anonymous, @RichM1, @Anonymous, @Anonymous, @Frank-Laudes, @karthur1, @DanSingleton, @Anonymous, @mcgyvr, @Anonymous, @ca-d.one, @Curtis_W, @ulasdeniz, @Anonymous,

Some possible solutions for this idea are currently under discussion on the NDA based Inventor Feedback/Beta forums. If you would like to contribute/validate then please apply for access using this link:   https://bit.ly/InventorBeta

 

Thanks, Dan

dan_szymanski
Autodesk

@P-D91, @SofiaGrave4819, @Anonymous, @dhaval3112, @Anonymous

Some possible solutions for this idea are currently under discussion on the NDA based Inventor Feedback/Beta forums. If you would like to contribute/validate then please apply for access using this link:   https://bit.ly/InventorBeta

 

Thanks, Dan

 

Lithium limited me to 20 @ mentions per comment.  Smiley Mad

RichM1
Contributor

I already have access. I don't see anything on this topic. Can you be more specific?

karthur1
Mentor

Look under Ideas - Enhancements & Usability under the forums.  Make sure your list is not filtered. If you cant find it shoot me a PM.

RichM1
Contributor

Found it. It auto applied a filter for some reason.

 

I added my 2 cents.

 

Sounds like it is making good progress.

dan_szymanski
Autodesk

Thanks guys - both @karthur1 & @RichM1 - Greatly appreciated!

jletcher
Advisor

I would still like to know why this was needed. I was not being a GOD how would someone learn if they don’t why?

 

 In all the years of manufacturing and thought I have seen it all even to this day I have never seen this need.

 

Not saying it is not needed with my “why” I was asking to learn.

 

 

Anonymous
Not applicable
Hi JLetcher,
The actual use is fairly simple. We make for instance cylinder rods, which are welded before machining. To follow the actual real parts path in Inventor this means a milling actions after we welded the cylinder eye to the rod. The rod gets external threads to fit into the piston.
[cid:[email protected]]
Except. I can't do it in Inventor.
Other example: mounting plate assemblies with mounting pins with external threads milled into them. (high precision welded parts)
Hope you no see its use.
jletcher
Advisor

@Anonymous

 

Thanks for the reply..

 

 The image did not post for some reason or another.

 

So I am still at a lost can you see if you can get image to upload?

 

I really would like to know the reason.. Like I said all the years I have never ran into a issue where the threads could not be put on 1st then welded...

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea