cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Update of Replace Model References in Drawings

Update of Replace Model References in Drawings

I think the replace reference tool is outdated and needs some improvements.

Allow the user to choose whether the change applies to:

  1. The entire file (currently)
  2. The current sheet
  3. Selected sheets
  4. One view
  5. Selected views
39 Comments
Anonymous
Not applicable

If 2 base views share the same model reference, only 1 reference is displayed.

If I edit that one, both base views are changed.

 

I've had several occassions that I wanted to change only one of them

 

Currently you see:

     Assembly1.iam (replace)

 

I would like to see:

    View 1 - Assembly1.iam (replace)

    View 5 - Assembly1.iam (replace)

Tags (2)
asiu
Advocate

Great suggestion!

 

I would also like to be able to replace an .iam with an .ipt and the other way around.

NeilClasby75
Advocate

Hi

 

I use the Replace Model Reference command in IDW all the time.  Great feature.

 

But I find the menu a bit of a pain.  I have to select the view, then go into the RMR window and find the view (ref) to replace.  Some IDW's may have 50 to 100 views of difference .iam models, and you can't expand the RMR window so lots of scrolling.  Not easy.

 

Just add RMR to the right-click menu of a view and jump straight to browser to find the file you wish to replace with.

 

Thanks. N.

krystianwiatr
Enthusiast

I just wanted to do same thing, and couldn't figure it out. It should be like in assembly, replace or replace all. Great idea!

krystianwiatr
Enthusiast
krystianwiatr
Enthusiast

I also found  idea to further improve that feature

https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/inventor-ideastation/idw-replace-model-reference-from-browser/idc-p/6...

I think they should be combined

iMaJiNe_Designs
Advocate

It would be nice if the model(s) path(s) could be edited at the drawing (.IDW) 'view' level dialog box instead of having to go to the 'manage' tab.

Tags (1)
DRoam
Mentor

Great idea. This way we could change it on a per-View basis rather than drawing-wide. Of course, it would also affect all children of the view.

DRoam
Mentor

Actually, I did a quick search, and this is the duplicate. The original is here: Replace Model Reference per base view

 

Please add your vote and comments to the original so feedback is not split between posts!

iMaJiNe_Designs
Advocate

Thanks for finding that article as I figured someone else would have the same request.

 

In my case I'm trying to correct neglected rookie file management mistakes from ages ago before migrating from Inventor 2016 to 2017.  I'm testing out my reorganization on old simple projects before I make a complete mess out of recently completed and current projects.

 

 

DRoam
Mentor

No problem 🙂

 

I gotcha. Based on specifically what you're trying to do, there are workarounds in regards to replacing model references that can speed up/make up for clunky or missing functionality. For example:

 

  • Using Design Assistant rather than "Replace Model Reference".
  • Using the brute-force-and-ignorance method of moving a currently-referenced model's file somewhere where Inventor won't find it, opening the drawing, and using the "Resolve file" dialog to choose the new file to reference.
  • If you need to replace a referenced file only in a few specific sheets of a Drawing, you can select them, copy them to a NEW drawing, delete the sheets you copied from the ORIGINAL drawing, go back to the NEW drawing and replace the references, then copy the sheets back to the ORIGINAL drawing

Definitely none of these are great. But there's a chance they could be faster for you.

iMaJiNe_Designs
Advocate

Thanks for the additional suggestions beyond 'Replace Model Reference;' but as you noted, none of these are great solutions either.  So now that I'm aware of 'Replace Model Reference' that is the least painful method for my needs.

 

I think it would make more sense to replace/repath a model in a drawing via the 'view properties' dialog box than switch to a different ribbon tab.

DRoam
Mentor

Agreed 🙂 I'd highly recommend voting on the original of this Idea if you'd like for this to be recognized and addressed by Autodesk, as the other one has been around longer and has a decent number of votes behind it. You can vote for it here: Replace Model Reference per base view.

iMaJiNe_Designs
Advocate

I just took your suggestion.  Thanks.

DRoam
Mentor
MikeKovacik4928
Advisor

I have also been wanting to do this and have found a work around which is very laborious.

See my post at  https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/inventor-forum/replace-model-reference-single-instance/m-p/7247534#M6...

I was about to post to idea forum, but see other  people have had same idea.

I fully support it and give my vote.

 

Michael Kovacik
AutoCAD 2d & 3d (29 yrs)& Inventor (7 yrs)
Manufacturing (30 yrs) Draughtsman/Designer
Autodesk Product Design Suite Ultimate 2018
Johannesburg, South Africa

 

Anonymous
Not applicable

This would also be helpful when it's possible to copy and paste a sheet in the same idw or dwg. 

Maybe it is handy to RMR with a right click on a sheet, right click on the idw/dwg total and right click on a view as you suggested. 

inv.ideareview
Autodesk
We’re archiving this Idea because it's been on the board for well over a year and hasn't received many votes from the community. If you want to raise it again and try to gain more support, you're welcome to do so.
inv.ideareview
Autodesk
Status changed to: Archived
 
Anonymous
Not applicable

I would like to raise this idea back up.  It is a great idea.  The fact that, in Inventor Pro 2019, we still can't simply change the component referenced for a specific drawing view, is awful.  That isn't user friendly.  I'd like to also point out the SolidWorks has had this since at least 2014.  Yet another reason I will likely be switching.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea