Emboss on sphere bug

Emboss on sphere bug

danielpoulsen1984
Participant Participant
4,537 Views
54 Replies
Message 1 of 55

Emboss on sphere bug

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

I am doing some work with semispheres and banging my head against the wall when it comes to accuracy on my embossed sketches and then I tried to simply emboss a 25mm circle on a 28mm sphere and the result is quite perplexing. Instead of delivering a clean round emboss, it becomes a wavy mess. And this is the same I am seeing in my other emboss results, when trying to emboss a circular design on the semisphere.

I can do some workarounds with using split face and others when it comes to simple design, but for more complex sketches(text in a circle for example), I don't see a workaround as of right now.

0 Likes
4,538 Views
54 Replies
Replies (54)
Message 2 of 55

TheCADWhisperer
Consultant
Consultant

@danielpoulsen1984 

What are you attempting to model?

This looks like a simple Revolve to me.

TheCADWhisperer_0-1746122106403.png

 

Message 3 of 55

jhackney1972
Consultant
Consultant

Create your sphere with a Revolved Semi-Circle and your will get better results.  Model example attached.

 

Emboss Sphere.jpg

John Hackney, Retired
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

Message 4 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

Hey John, thanks for the quick reply, but that unfortunately doesn't change anything.

 

danielpoulsen1984_0-1746122438426.png

 

0 Likes
Message 5 of 55

TrippyLighting
Consultant
Consultant

Frist, I would not use a sphere primitive. Then I would not use the move tool either.

See the attached model.

 

TrippyLighting_1-1746122683825.png

 


EESignature

Message 6 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

It doesn't actually change anything adding a semicircle around it. The example you just uploaded also has the same flaw:

 

danielpoulsen1984_1-1746122798401.png

 

The bigger you make the sketch compared to the circle, the worse the distortions get.

 

Here the circle is 50% bigger:

 

danielpoulsen1984_2-1746122866543.png

 

And 100% bigger:

 

danielpoulsen1984_3-1746122906593.png

 

So to me, this is a clear bug and should be reported to devs.

0 Likes
Message 7 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

My designs are much more complex, some even containing text and can't be handled by simply using revolve. Think logos on a sphere.

0 Likes
Message 8 of 55

jhackney1972
Consultant
Consultant

There is a limited to the size of the sketch you can use to wrap around the sphere.  In the attached screen capture I have a 200 mm diameter sphere and a 250 mm Embossed Circle, it is getting a little flaky.

 

Emboss on Sphere Oversize.jpg

John Hackney, Retired
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

0 Likes
Message 9 of 55

TheCADWhisperer
Consultant
Consultant

@danielpoulsen1984 wrote:

My designs are much more complex, some even containing text and can't be handled by simply using revolve. Think logos on a sphere.


Then let's move on to the true Design Intent.

This one was a simple Revolve.

Message 10 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

Hence me reporting this as a bug 😁 It’s clear that the emboss is not wrapping the sphere correctly and some development power is needed to fix this.

Message 11 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

I can’t divulge the exact information as I am working on a startup. But think regular circular company logos. I need them to wrap halfway around a sphere at max and I can’t get the emboss tool to work correctly as shown in the above posts. This is the reason for my post. 

For simpler design I can do hacks with centering the design in chunks or using the regular tools like revolve etc, but alignment is then almost always an issue. 

0 Likes
Message 12 of 55

TrippyLighting
Consultant
Consultant

Then I would suggest you post relevant examples not dumbed down stuff!

 


EESignature

0 Likes
Message 13 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

The example is relevant to show the bug I am reporting….. even if “dumbed down”.

0 Likes
Message 14 of 55

TheCADWhisperer
Consultant
Consultant

@danielpoulsen1984 

Make up a dummy file that exhibits the same behavior as your proprietary data.

 

0 Likes
Message 15 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

Imagine the letters curved perfectly in a circle, these are just quickly typed in and moved to the edge of the sketch to emboss down on the sphere. But it is clear to see that the logo which is circular isn't embossed with a straight curve, hence the logo looking "wonky" and the text alignment as well.

0 Likes
Message 16 of 55

TrippyLighting
Consultant
Consultant

@danielpoulsen1984 wrote:

The example is relevant to show the bug I am reporting….. even if “dumbed down”.


Agreed, and reporting a bug is appreciated! (this one is known and has been reported on the forum previously @Phil.E )

However, you'll have to work around it and an example representative of what you are trying to achieve is going to be helpfull.


EESignature

Message 17 of 55

TheCADWhisperer
Consultant
Consultant

@danielpoulsen1984 

The sketches do not meet my quality standards, and I doubt I would use emboss function for this design.

 

I doubt I would use a Sphere primitive, and don't see a need for a Move.

Message 18 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

I am a novice in using the product and I am not even sure what you are saying, but thank you for sharing your insight.

0 Likes
Message 19 of 55

TheCADWhisperer
Consultant
Consultant

@danielpoulsen1984 wrote:

I am a novice in using the product, but thank you for sharing your insight.


That is what I suspected which means it will be all the more difficult to decipher the true Design Intent and help you arrive at a solution.

It may take several days of back-and-forth discussion.

Message 20 of 55

danielpoulsen1984
Participant
Participant

I can do it with a “hack-ish” approach, but in reality, I am just looking to report this bug and have it fixed, so I can work with the product as intended. 

As said, I am a novice and just getting into this, but I am not going to buy a license when my current primary use isn’t even working as intended, causing me to spend hours upon hours manually aligning things and getting a less than perfect result.

 

If you feel like there is a better way to do this, feel free to share some pointers, I don’t mind spending hours to learn, but I’m running out of ideas to search for in regards to this issue.

0 Likes