ThroughAllExtentDefinition fails to extrude almost always

[siliconlad]

This might be me not understanding how to use it correctly (I've taken a look at this post, but that didn't help me much).

I have created a sketch point, construction plane and circular sketch that is parallel to the face of the cube as shown in the image below. I would like to then run a script which extrudes this sketch through the cube.

When I try and use the `ThroughAllExtentDefition`, like below:

app = adsk.core.Application.get()
design = adsk.fusion.Design.cast(app.activeProduct)
root = design.rootComponent
extrudes = root.features.extrudeFeatures

extent = adsk.fusion.ThroughAllExtentDefinition.create()
e_input = extrudes.createInput(profile, adsk.fusion.FeatureOperations.CutFeatureOperation)
e_input.setTwoSidesExtent(extent, extent)
extrudes.add(e_input)  # Create extrude

It fails with the following error:

Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "C:\Users/angus/AppData/Roaming/Autodesk/Autodesk Fusion 360/API/AddIns/cadify-fusion\commands\agent\operations\helper.py", line 130, in try_op
    f()
  File "C:\Users/angus/AppData/Roaming/Autodesk/Autodesk Fusion 360/API/AddIns/cadify-fusion\commands\agent\operations\extrude.py", line 46, in two_sides_extent
    extrudes.add(e_input)  # Create extrude
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
  File "C:\Users/angus/AppData/Local/Autodesk/webdeploy/production/b0c303e70bd97cfdc195adab65922cfeffcb363a/Api/Python/packages\adsk\fusion.py", line 20926, in add
    return _fusion.ExtrudeFeatures_add(self, input)
           ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
RuntimeError: 5 : EXTRUDE_CREATION_FAIL_ERROR - Cannot complete extrusion.

But I can see the extrude in the timeline and when I manually click, 'Edit Feature' then click `Ok` without changing anything it successfully creates the extrude cut.

Sometimes I have the sketch on a curved surface like

And I get the error

Cadify: Failed to execute operation: 2 : InternalValidationError : isCalFarestBody
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "C:\Users/angus/AppData/Roaming/Autodesk/Autodesk Fusion 360/API/AddIns/cadify-fusion\commands\agent\operations\helper.py", line 130, in try_op
    f()
  File "C:\Users/angus/AppData/Roaming/Autodesk/Autodesk Fusion 360/API/AddIns/cadify-fusion\commands\agent\operations\extrude.py", line 71, in negative_extent
    extrudes.add(e_input)  # Create extrude
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
  File "C:\Users/angus/AppData/Local/Autodesk/webdeploy/production/b0c303e70bd97cfdc195adab65922cfeffcb363a/Api/Python/packages\adsk\fusion.py", line 20926, in add
    return _fusion.ExtrudeFeatures_add(self, input)
           ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
RuntimeError: 2 : InternalValidationError : isCalFarestBody

Whereas in all the situations, using the `DistanceExtentDefinition` works perfectly fine. Is there a reason behind this?

[john.kirchner]

I'm able to reproduce this issue, it looks like a bug. I've logged this to a ticket to be fixed - thank you for finding and posting this!

[siliconlad]

No worries! Is there a way to track when this gets fixed? 

[john.kirchner]

We don't have anything public facing but I could see this issue being picked up fairly quickly, so hopefully a fix will be included in the next release. I can post here when that becomes clearer

[siliconlad]

Thank you!

[john.kirchner]

The fix for this issue will be included in the release towards the end of March, thank you for your patience!

[siliconlad · Accepted solution]

Seems to work now!