Data exchange between Advance Steel and Tekla

[EmreKasıkcı]

Hello,

After opening Advance Steel files in Tekla, to what extent can we make modifications? Can I extract connection details to Tekla? Conversely, can I open and edit Tekla files in Advance Steel? Do you have any experience or recommendations regarding this matter?

Regards

[EmreKasıkcı]

Hello,

After opening Advance Steel files in Tekla, to what extent can we make modifications? Can I extract connection details to Tekla? Conversely, can I open and edit Tekla files in Advance Steel? Do you have any experience or recommendations regarding this matter?

Regards

[sdonohoedesign]

There is no information exchange between AS & Tekla.

You can reference ACIS / .DWG models into both softwares but these will be reference models only, you won't get anything intelligent / editable.

[sdonohoedesign]

There is no information exchange between AS & Tekla.

You can reference ACIS / .DWG models into both softwares but these will be reference models only, you won't get anything intelligent / editable.

[Sebastian_Eiche · Accepted solution]

This is not correct at all.
For Tekla and Advance Steel there's the CIS/2 Import/Export , with the limitations of this file format. But to it should work to get plates, beams and bolts.

If you get the CIS/2 from Tekla use the "special CIS/2 import"

Depending on the version of Tekla and the Export settings, sometimes the IFC files are working

[Sebastian_Eiche · Accepted solution]

This is not correct at all.
For Tekla and Advance Steel there's the CIS/2 Import/Export , with the limitations of this file format. But to it should work to get plates, beams and bolts.

If you get the CIS/2 from Tekla use the "special CIS/2 import"

Depending on the version of Tekla and the Export settings, sometimes the IFC files are working

[egidijus_drafting · Accepted solution]

It is nightmare, however I found from Tekla to ADVS best would be IFC file with certain instruction.

[egidijus_drafting · Accepted solution]

It is nightmare, however I found from Tekla to ADVS best would be IFC file with certain instruction.

[sdonohoedesign · Accepted solution]

OK.  I stand corrected.  But my 9 years AS experience has taught me......

You may be able to use these formats to transfer some of your data through, but you are going to spend a lot of time to make it usable.  It won't be something you can rely on for ongoing projects.

If you come to produce your fab pack and you get errors / crashing I can guarantee you this is something to do with your imported data.  When you need to get your project issued and you are fighting against the system you will realise that you would have been quicker to start from scratch, or you may even end up starting from scratch.

Never import anything into your AS model files.  I have learned this the hard way.......

Although saying that, I believe that every single error has been repaired between my AS2018 and latest AS2025 so my experience is probably no longer valid.

[sdonohoedesign · Accepted solution]

OK.  I stand corrected.  But my 9 years AS experience has taught me......

You may be able to use these formats to transfer some of your data through, but you are going to spend a lot of time to make it usable.  It won't be something you can rely on for ongoing projects.

If you come to produce your fab pack and you get errors / crashing I can guarantee you this is something to do with your imported data.  When you need to get your project issued and you are fighting against the system you will realise that you would have been quicker to start from scratch, or you may even end up starting from scratch.

Never import anything into your AS model files.  I have learned this the hard way.......

Although saying that, I believe that every single error has been repaired between my AS2018 and latest AS2025 so my experience is probably no longer valid.

[Sebastian_Eiche · Accepted solution]

I don't want to say it work perfect...but there's a way. From my point I never use this data too, I always use it as reference, but the "old" fileformats like CIS/2 and so on and working mostly better then IFC from my experience.

[Sebastian_Eiche · Accepted solution]

I don't want to say it work perfect...but there's a way. From my point I never use this data too, I always use it as reference, but the "old" fileformats like CIS/2 and so on and working mostly better then IFC from my experience.

[willem.creffierKCWFB · Accepted solution]

I use the export through Revit for IFC, and it works quite well.

If only there was a way to send along 1 single identifier that applies to all the object types......

[willem.creffierKCWFB · Accepted solution]

I use the export through Revit for IFC, and it works quite well.

If only there was a way to send along 1 single identifier that applies to all the object types......

[egidijus_drafting]

Absolutely agree with @sdonohoedesign  comments – specially if working with curved members, normally we just ask clients for system lines and then rebuild them from the scratch.

[egidijus_drafting]

Absolutely agree with @sdonohoedesign  comments – specially if working with curved members, normally we just ask clients for system lines and then rebuild them from the scratch.