- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Mute
- Subscribe to RSS Feed
- Permalink
- Report
Hi,
I am cross checking robot design of a column with hand calculation and the first thing i have noticed is that the clear height of the column as well as the effective length of a column is wrongly calculated by Robot.
Clear height of column
as you can see from the picture below the height of the column is 3.0m, and the depth of the beam is 0.55m therefore the clear height of the column, L is 3.0m - 0.55 m = 2.45m
As you can see from the second picture the clear height used by robot is 3.00m which is the whole height of the column.
Effective length of column
Then the effective length of the column, Lo is calculated by:
Lo = L x factor (depending on the fixitity of the column at top and bottom)
possible values of Lo are
pinned at both ends, Lo = L = 2.45m
cantilever column, Lo = 2 x L = 5.0m
fixed at bottom, pinned at top, Lo = 0.7 x 2.45 = 1.715m
fixed at both ends, Lo = 0.5 x 2.45 = 1.225m
fixed at bottom, roller on top, Lo = L = 2.45m
Considering the fact that Robot calculated the same value for both clear and effective height it means that robot considers the column pinned at both ends or fixed at bottom and roller at top which i think both are wrong.
Anyone knows what is the problem here?
Solved! Go to Solution.