Scheduling analytical results from Robot in Revit

[renan.jose]

Hi, i do need to schedule the analytical results received from Robot in Revit. The "results explorer" works great to visually view results but i don't know how to update the analytical results of each member since they don't show data when i try to schedule. It seems like to analytical results are not connected to the properties of the analytical members. For example, this would especially be handy when one does column load-rundowns to simple extract the results through schedules of all columns at each level. What do i need to do to make it work ?

This is the file in which i'm trying to generate the schedule with results from Robot: 

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sNZyLJmn6EfDsQjxOL49z3C7FBFBvX38/view?usp=sharing

Thanks,

[erik_snell]

Thank you for your post. At this time there is no way to access the results in a schedule.

If it was possible what types of schedules would you create?

[loprast711]

The only way is if you use Excel Result Connect from Robot Structural Analysis to import but, to do it in revit, for now, as far as i know, is impossible. The analytical schedule from revit was for a old plug-in in revit that was possible to analize the structure inside revit but, Autodesk remove it because of some issues like every time that u changed something in the structure, ur analytical model changed it to, so revit have to analized everything again in other to you continue.

[renan.jose]

Hello Erik, I would like to have the Fz reactions for base columns so I can calculate in the same schedule the size of the foundation footings. Do you have any idea on how to make it work without using external files in a dynamic way that can be updated according any future design changes ? Thanks

[erik_snell]

I do not know of a way to automatically accomplish this via the UI. There may be ways using the API or Dynamo and Excel. I'm not overly familiar with these tools/workflows.

There are properties in columns/beams for end reactions. You could manually fill these parameters from the RSA results. These properties are schedulable.

Thank you for sharing your use case. I will be sure to pass it along. I have a few inquiries out to colleagues if I hear anything I will post here.

Cheers.

[renan.jose]

Hello Erik, thanks for trying to help, I saw this video from Autodesk building solutions YouTube channel called "integration of BIM and structural analysis" https://youtu.be/kab2WdXEUBg and i just would like to work this out without external tools (Excel) and without adding those parameters manually so the schedule calculations can be as dynamic as possible, I mean, changing the values according the design and load changes according BIM philosophy. Since it is a pretty basic function compared with the video and since there are many schedule parameters regarding analytical values (including loads and reactions) I wonder if it's really not possible or if I just don't know how to do it properly. Thanks

[loprast711]

Have u already tried Dynamo?

[AAbdelsattarQQTGU]

any updates for this issue??