Schedule of pipe slope

Schedule of pipe slope

arqyt
Advocate Advocate
8,100 Views
27 Replies
Message 1 of 28

Schedule of pipe slope

arqyt
Advocate
Advocate

Can you get a schedule table that indicate pipe slope?
Apparently it seems not.
I am perplexed

Jose M Carralero.
ArqyT
0 Likes
Accepted solutions (1)
8,101 Views
27 Replies
Replies (27)
Message 21 of 28

RSomppi
Mentor
Mentor

How is scheduling pipe slopes used? I've never seen individual pipes scheduled except in fabrication and still the slopes are shown on plans.

0 Likes
Message 22 of 28

brownbr2VHQE
Contributor
Contributor

For me quality control.

0 Likes
Message 23 of 28

RSomppi
Mentor
Mentor

@brownbr2VHQE wrote:

For me quality control.


That doesn't really explain the workflow. How is it being used?

0 Likes
Message 24 of 28

brownbr2VHQE
Contributor
Contributor

Make a pipe schedule sorted by Slope > fix ones that aren't the correct slope...

0 Likes
Message 25 of 28

RLY_15
Advisor
Advisor

There's possible application in drainage workflows - both waste fixture unit calculations as well as stormwater calculations could benefit from having a slope parameter to assist driving calculated parameters that determine flow rate or pipe size.

 

The simple answer to the lack of scheduling feature is that they 'probably' could not or did not want to reconcile the case of vertical pipes. The storage type of the slope parameter is 'number' but this means that vertical pipes are Undefined - I wonder how the Calculated Parameter feature interacts (if at all) with undefined values. Regardless, do you want the pipe schedule to say 'Undefined'? Revit would have to specifically identify that the Slope parameter, when Undefined, should read 'Vertical' in schedules...that frankly sounds like a lot of work that is easier to push onto the users, and @iainsavage 's link to past work shows the user solution.

0 Likes
Message 26 of 28

RSomppi
Mentor
Mentor

@RLY_15 wrote:

The storage type of the slope parameter is 'number' but this means that vertical pipes are Undefined


I get "Not Computed".

 

RSomppi_0-1747166711642.png

 

 


@RLY_15 wrote:

There's possible application in drainage workflows


Thanks. I see now that I wrongly assumed that this was for scheduling on sheets.

0 Likes
Message 27 of 28

RLY_15
Advisor
Advisor

It might be, I may have misinterpreted earlier posts.

 

Sheet scheduling could have benefit on retrofit buildings where you may need to demonstrate 1% vs 2% laterals to AHJs, but I would have typically expected to see that sort of notation on the floor plans themselves.

 

"Not Computed" is Revit's display of 1/0. I work a little too much in the Dynamo environment and erroneously said Undefined which is the output in Dynamo.

Message 28 of 28

iainsavage
Mentor
Mentor

Vertical pipes show as not computed.

See part 13 of the other post which I gave the link to earlier.

0 Likes