cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Thin Extrusion Feature

Thin Extrusion Feature

Please implement the ability to extrude thin features already. Trying to do injection molded parts is so tedious without this ability.

 

Currently you have to either...

1) Overcomplicate the sketches by 10x. Ensure that your sketches are 100% perfect. And never change anything. If you change anything it is almost certain that they crash because they have 10x as many sketch constraints as you actually need. This is further complicated because Inventor can't find closed spaces unless there is a point at every corner... So a single constraint out of the hundreds in the overcomplicated sketch are no longer real, it all crashes.

 

or...

 

2) you have to convert every line to a surface and thicken it. Problem is you can only do one surface at a time. For even a simple molded part this could be hundreds of different ribs and pockets walls. And if you have equation based or "Extrude To" functionallity, forget about it... You will be at it all day.

 

This is not a new thing... This post goes back 13 years asking how to do this... https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/inventor-forum/thin-extrusion/td-p/1022578

 

This one goes back 8 years... http://www.mcadcentral.com/threads/824-How-to-make-thin-features

 

Maybe I am missing something but this is a simple checkbox in SolidWorks. Super obvious, super easy, and probably 10x more stable. In the example below, Inventor would have taken at least twice as many features, 4x as many coincident mates, concentric mates, etc...

3 Comments
michael_marx
Advocate

why you do not use the rip feature??

Anonymous
Not applicable

SO Frustrated with Inventor 2019 been using it for 3 months with my business, the amount of errors the sheetmetal feature throws out is beyond reason, with SW it easily does sheetmetal, so to work around the problem I try to create a thin-feature just to realise you can't.... really? CREO and SW has this feature, come on,

andyDKFUQ
Contributor

Yes this does seem weird.  We are currently using Alibre Design Expert which is a dumpster fire but even that does thin extrudes. Solidworks in 1995, 25 years ago did thin extrudes (it did thin lofts and sweeps from 2001 too, 18 years ago). Such a basic feature to exclude?!  As you say, overcomplicated sketching is required as a result.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea