cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Better Select Other Functionality

Better Select Other Functionality

In Pro/Engineer, a series of quick Right Clicks prehighlights each item that is directly under your pointer from top (closest to the pointer) to bottom. You then need to Left-Click the prehighlighted feature to actually select it. Holding Ctrl then allows you to repeat and add features to the selection set, if desired.

 

If you were to then Right Click and hold for a slightly longer time, the shortcut menu then comes up, allowing you to modify the feature, etc.

 

This is a MUCH faster way of selecting hidden geometry, faces, features, etc., than the Inventor method of using the Select Other button, especially when working with multiple selections.

 

With Pro/Engineer, I can go Right, Left, Hold Control, Right, Right, Left, Right, Right, Right, Left and now have three overlaying or hidden features, surfaces, or edges selected, in less time than it takes to get to the Select Other command.

4 Comments
DRoam
Mentor

The Select Other command now has a keyboard shortcut assigned to it. It's Ctrl+A by default, but it can be customized.

 

I agree that's not optimal, though. The list is annoying and unnecessary to me. In AutoCAD, Shift+Spacebar does what you're saying right-click does in Pro/E. I personally like that better as I would HATE having to do a long-press right-click whenever I want to use a context menu. That would drive me batty.

 

There's a somewhat related feature request HERE for the ability to trickle through hierarchy levels using a keyboard modifier and the scroll wheel. This is slightly different from your request but similar. Your request is for the ability to toggle through objects behind (or near) where the cursor is at, but at the same hierarchy level. The request I've linked to is for the ability to trickle through actual hierarchy (i.e. assembly and pattern) levels.

 

I bring that up to say this: it would be really powerful if, say, shift+scroll trickled through hierarchy levels, while shift+space toggled through components behind/near the cursor at the current hierarchy level. This would give us complete control over what we're selecting purely in the graphics window, without ever having to dig through the browser tree.

rjensen
Explorer

Thanks for the reply, DRoam. I tried Crtl+A and it just doesn't help.

 

When I say a long-press right click, I'm talking about the difference between a quick click and a click and hold for maybe 0.2 seconds.

 

The difference between Pro/E and Inventor is that you have to left-click a selection in order to be able to right click to get the short-cut menu. (If you then hold Ctrl and left-click, it knows you want to select more features.) In Inventor, the program assumes you want to select what is just under the cursor when you right click, doing away with the need to left click. 

 

I see what you are asking for with using the scroll wheel, but I think that modifying the click action is faster and more efficient.

 

Maybe the best way to handle this is to keep the current selection system as is and add a function that becomes active with a right-click-hold.

 

So now, you right-click and the short-cut menu pops up. Hold slightly longer and the first feature, surface, or edge (depending on selection priority) highlights. Right-click again and the next highlights. Repeat as necessary. When the feature you want highlights, left-click and you can go from there.

CAD_CAM_MAN
Advocate

Kudos given, you are right on, Pro Engineers method is so much better. I miss that functionality since switching to Inventor. I hope Autodesk will do something similar.

LukeDavenport
Collaborator

 

We definitely need better Select Other ability. Revit allows you to simply hit TAB key as many times as you want to find the item you want behind the cursor. SO MUCH FASTER! Select other is very clunky by comparison.

 

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea