Newbie - Questions about Projected Geometry & Axis Creation

Newbie - Questions about Projected Geometry & Axis Creation

timothy_crouse
Collaborator Collaborator
403 Views
3 Replies
Message 1 of 4

Newbie - Questions about Projected Geometry & Axis Creation

timothy_crouse
Collaborator
Collaborator

If someone has time could you explain/clarify the following:

 

Can projected geometry lines be modified on the projected plane or do projected lines remain just that "projected" to be used for reference and intersecting points to construct new geometry on the current work plane?

 

Can projected lines be separated from the projected plane and used as construction lines on the current work plane through a property setting or something of the sort?

 

Once projected lines have been created and used can they be deleted or will the object lines that originally use them become "underconstrained"?

 

 

Other than using an axis to snap parts together in an assembly when would an axis be created inside a sketch?  I am not understanding the relevance of an axis inside a sketch when you can create any form of the work plane and project geometry as required to create new reference points.

 

Thanks in Advance

-Tim C.

 

 

 

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (1)
404 Views
3 Replies
Replies (3)
Message 2 of 4

EdvinTailwind
Collaborator
Collaborator

In the 3D Sketch - right click and choose Delete Constraints. Exit the sketch and now you can delete the original projected 2D Sketch and/or surface(s). The contraints have been removed and the 3D Sketch can "live" on it's own.

EdvinTailwind_0-1643489895123.png

 

Regarding the assembly question I'm not sure. Maybe you want to be able to animate a part along an axis?

Message 3 of 4

pcrawley
Advisor
Advisor
Accepted solution

1 - Can projected geometry lines be modified on the projected plane or do projected lines remain just that "projected" to be used for reference and intersecting points to construct new geometry on the current work plane?

 

Projected lines can be modified if you remove the "Projected" sketch constraint from the projected entity:

01.jpg

This image shows the projected entity (the edge of the extrusion) - then deleting the projected geometry sketch constraint, and then the line behaves just like any other sketch geometry.  There's nothing special about projected geometry - it's just regular sketch geometry, but it comes from another source object.

 

Be careful with cross-part projected geometry in an Assembly because that can (depending on an Application Options setting) create "adaptive" geometry.  Adaptive geometry is very powerful - and very dangerous when used unwittingly! 

 

 

2 - Can projected lines be separated from the projected plane and used as construction lines on the current work plane through a property setting or something of the sort?

 

Projected geometry (and regular sketch geometry) can't be separated from the current plane individually.  You can redefine an entire sketch to a new plane, but I'm not sure that is your question.  Might need more explanation to understand what you're trying to achieve.

 

3 - Once projected lines have been created and used can they be deleted or will the object lines that originally use them become "underconstrained"?

 

Projected geometry can be deleted, but just like a regular sketch, if you delete something you've used for a dimension, the dimension gets deleted with the geometry.  You may have seen a scenario where the source object got deleted (or moved): That will leave behind pink projected geometry - indicating that the projection process is broken.  Remove the Projected Geometry sketch constraint to fix it. (Note that in the example below you'd remove the sketch constraint from the line and the two endpoints.)

 

02.jpg

This shows the same example as previously, but I went back to the original extrusion and effectively "deleted" the edge which I had projected.

 

4 - Other than using an axis to snap parts together in an assembly when would an axis be created inside a sketch?  I am not understanding the relevance of an axis inside a sketch when you can create any form of the work plane and project geometry as required to create new reference points.

 

There isn't an axis creation tool in the Sketch environment - it is a 3d model feature.  You can project an axis into a sketch the create either a line or a point - but you're right, there's no point in having an axis in a sketch.

 

Hope that helps.

Peter
Message 4 of 4

timothy_crouse
Collaborator
Collaborator
Thank You Guys for your answers, big help
-Tim C.
0 Likes