Horsepower, in many respects, is only going to be as good as your workholding. There's little value in a massive spindle if your vacuum table or clamps aren't up to the task.
While I don't have a huge amount of experience with wood routers, I do know that a lot of people use 2.25 HP router spindles in their semi-industrial machines (Avid CNC and the like).
Spindle speed is where my interest would be, especially if you're doing surfacing on a regular basis. What's the largest bit you expect to use? The larger the cutting tool, the more HP you're going to need. If you're staying under a half inch (12mm) you should be fine with a 3-4hp, provided you don't plan on dropping down 2" and trying to make it all in one cut. (exception to this would be a surfacing tool where you're taking light axial cuts)
One of the bigger concerns with gantry routers is the rigidity; is the machine (z axis) going to flex when you take a heavy cut?
Seth Madore
Customer Advocacy Manager - Manufacturing