Why can I not select the intersection between two construction circles?

Why can I not select the intersection between two construction circles?

eldavid0000
Contributor Contributor
1,826 Views
8 Replies
Message 1 of 9

Why can I not select the intersection between two construction circles?

eldavid0000
Contributor
Contributor

Please see the attached F3D file exported.  It is for design of a GT2 pulley profile.

 

First see inside Sketch 4 (a new sketch), where the construction lines are inside Sketch 1.

 

Using the Point tool see the following areas and behavior of the program:

eldavid0000_0-1684713425856.png

 

At the top of the circle construction shown here, you can see a box is created at the intersection of the circle and another line.  This circle is Tangent to that line (and intersects it).  

eldavid0000_1-1684713493855.png

 

 

This square does NOT appear when attempting to hover over and create a point at the intersection shown here, where two circle constructions are Tangent to one another (and intersecting):

eldavid0000_2-1684713561586.png

 

Now attempt the same inside Sketch 1:  The Tangent constraints are clearly shown now (see symbol). 

 

Intersection at top gets indicated as a square when attempting to place a point there as is expected. 

eldavid0000_3-1684713666811.png

 

Intersection between circles does not show the intersection when hovering over it.

eldavid0000_4-1684713809201.png

 

 

 

 

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (1)
1,827 Views
8 Replies
Replies (8)
Message 2 of 9

eldavid0000
Contributor
Contributor

Changing one of the circles into a regular line instead of a construction line does not help:

eldavid0000_0-1684714014308.png

 

0 Likes
Message 3 of 9

etfrench
Mentor
Mentor

Double posting is frowned on😁

ETFrench

EESignature

0 Likes
Message 4 of 9

eldavid0000
Contributor
Contributor

This is a standalone issue that I am having.  File and steps to reproduce are shown clearly.  

 

Yes, I replied to a year old thread (stale but unclosed?) posting my file but I am not sure if it is directly related.  If it can help them resolve their issue then I am happy to contribute but next time can just leave the thread silent. 

0 Likes
Message 5 of 9

etfrench
Mentor
Mentor

See response in the other thread.

ETFrench

EESignature

0 Likes
Message 6 of 9

davebYYPCU
Consultant
Consultant

A couple of things (without reading the file)

 

If you hide sketch 1, when working in sketch 4, there is nothing to snap to.

Working in sketch 4, needs sketch 1 articles projected into it.

 

Construction Point Menu - points, - are not the same as sketch points.

 

3d triad, indicate that your not working in a 2d sketch, so 2d sketch tools will be unavailable.

 

That said, you have not said, what you want in sketch 4.

 

Might help.....

0 Likes
Message 7 of 9

eldavid0000
Contributor
Contributor

I wanted to use the point tool to create a point where the two circles intersect. 

0 Likes
Message 8 of 9

davebYYPCU
Consultant
Consultant

Presumably a Sketch point, not Work (Construction) Point, 

Fusion has never placed points at intersections, you have to create them

 

Ed has mentioned two methods.

 

Might help....

0 Likes
Message 9 of 9

eldavid0000
Contributor
Contributor
Accepted solution

Got it - thanks for replying - I am getting used to these forums and I thought I was replying to something >1yr old and potentially stale. 

 

Regarding your reply:

 

"You get the square when the cursor is over an endpoint, not necessarily coincident.  There are at least two ways to find the tangent point between two circles.  One: Use the Break command on one of the circles.  Two: Draw a line between the centers of the circles and trim or break the line.   Note: In you file, you have overlapping lines which is almost always a bad thing to do.  The endpoint of one of the lines will display the square.  Delete the circle and the other line and the square will still be displayed."

 

I started with the 2nd option drawing a line between the circles, because I was afraid breaking would break in an inexact place -- that worked well.  

 

eldavid0000_0-1684715673917.png

 

Then I tried breaking the circles at their intersection directly, and that seemed to also work.   An x seemed to snap to the point of their intersection.

eldavid0000_1-1684715937336.png

 

 

If the program was smart enough to do the above I am not sure why it had trouble creating a point at the intersection between the circles.  I guess the simple answer might be 1) that it's not supposed to or 2) they forgot to implement that.  

 

 

0 Likes