Find leak in sketch geometry

Find leak in sketch geometry

Helmi74
Collaborator Collaborator
13,906 Views
25 Replies
Message 1 of 26

Find leak in sketch geometry

Helmi74
Collaborator
Collaborator

Hi,

 

i did a relatively simple sketch geometry with some parametric values. I've been quite careful, used constraints as much as possible but still end up having a geometry which somehow isn't closed in the eyes of fusion. It doesn't show my geometry as closed and i can't do push pull and other things you would expect.


After inspecting visually i can't find anything problematic. What would be the right steps to follow to get rid of this problem?


Unfortunately i can't publish this document at the moment.

 

Thanks for helping

---
Frank / @helmi

Established 1974. Internet addicted since 1994. Collector of Kudos.
0 Likes
13,907 Views
25 Replies
Replies (25)
Message 21 of 26

TheCADWhisperer
Consultant
Consultant

White dots = missing coincident constraints.

Blue lines = unconstrained geometry.

 

When in doubt - click and drag white dots.

What do you observe?

 

White Dots.PNG

 

Extra Lines.PNG

 

Why sketch extra lines?  Get lazy!  Only sketch that which is needed.

Message 22 of 26

j9lemmon
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Click and drag white dots is great advice. Thanks @TheCADWhisperer

 

0 Likes
Message 23 of 26

etfrench
Mentor
Mentor

About 15 seconds to find the problem.  10 seconds were used to extend the lines where the white dots show non-coincident endpoints and 5 seconds to window select the geometry above the crossing line, right mouse click, then selecting Move to Sketch Plane from the context menu.

ETFrench

EESignature

Message 24 of 26

j9lemmon
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Thanks @etfrench - very useful details. 

0 Likes
Message 25 of 26

j9lemmon
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

I figured out how to use Sketch Checker to highlight leaks in sketches (very simple). 

⦁ do Edit Sketch for the Sketch that's leaking
⦁ at Top, choose Inspect - Sketch Checker
⦁ white dots that turn gray might cause the leak

 

The link to download Sketch Checker is above in this discussion.

0 Likes
Message 26 of 26

j9lemmon
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Using the advice above, especially from @etfrench and @TheCADWhisperer , I spent 30 minutes experimenting with adding constraints and other fixes for a leaky sketch. Here's what I observed:

⦁ Goal 1: eliminate white dots that show without being selected.
⦁ Goal 2: on mouse rollover, the sketch should turn black [ if Show Profile is checked in Sketch Palette]

⦁ After applying a constraint, press ESC key to exit that tool
⦁ Any white dot is a likely source of a leak. Move the dot around with mouse & observe; this gives clues about how much the segments adjoining that dot are constrained.

 

To apply a constraint to multiple segments:
⦁ do Edit Sketch
⦁ at Top, select a Constraint
⦁ click on a segment, then a second segment. EG select Parallel Constraint, click a segment, then a 2nd segment, and the Parallel constraint will appear.
⦁ If two adjoining lines are NOT connected to each other, try to Extend one of the lines. Do Edit Sketch - at Top choose Modify - Extend, then click a segment to extend it past the offending white dot, then do Modify - Trim to Trim what's over-extended.

 

These tips and my terminology, so I'd love improvements from those with more experience.

Thanks again for the help.

 

 

0 Likes