Reopend: Wind analysis stil keeps failing - help!?

[AntonioCampanario]

Dear Autodesk,

please fix the wind analysis since the past week every attempt failed!

Already posted this in another topic about failing wind analysis, but so far no satisfactory reply.

So copied my posts into this new post hoping for a faster solution:

--------------------------

as posted on 9-21-2023:

--------------------------

Hi Per,

what to do when the terrain is not to steep (like our country the netherlands) but the wind analysis keep failing?

Somehow multiple attempts failed but can not figur out why.

just started a new attempt  ...

Ran/Run analysis:

sunhours, succesfull

daylight, succesfull

wind, failed & running new... and once again failed

microclimate, succesfull

operational, no need

noise, no need

--------------------------

as posted on 9-26-2023:

--------------------------

"weekly update"

Update 26-9:

original project with combined data since 19-9-2023

re-created a simplified version of the project with openstreet map data only

re-created a simplified version of the project with NL data only

Unknown cause of failures...

--------------------------

as posted on 9-27-2023:

--------------------------

In the meantime tried to simplify the model even further hoping this would solve the problem.

recreated the project using NL data only, no succes!

recreated the project using open straatmap data only, no succes!

recreated the project with flat terrain, no succes!

Do hope the issue can be found swiftly so it can be fixed!

[AntonioCampanario]

Dear Autodesk,

please fix the wind analysis since the past week every attempt failed!

Already posted this in another topic about failing wind analysis, but so far no satisfactory reply.

So copied my posts into this new post hoping for a faster solution:

--------------------------

as posted on 9-21-2023:

--------------------------

Hi Per,

what to do when the terrain is not to steep (like our country the netherlands) but the wind analysis keep failing?

Somehow multiple attempts failed but can not figur out why.

just started a new attempt  ...

Ran/Run analysis:

sunhours, succesfull

daylight, succesfull

wind, failed & running new... and once again failed

microclimate, succesfull

operational, no need

noise, no need

--------------------------

as posted on 9-26-2023:

--------------------------

"weekly update"

Update 26-9:

original project with combined data since 19-9-2023

re-created a simplified version of the project with openstreet map data only

re-created a simplified version of the project with NL data only

Unknown cause of failures...

--------------------------

as posted on 9-27-2023:

--------------------------

In the meantime tried to simplify the model even further hoping this would solve the problem.

recreated the project using NL data only, no succes!

recreated the project using open straatmap data only, no succes!

recreated the project with flat terrain, no succes!

Do hope the issue can be found swiftly so it can be fixed!

[jon.ryfetten]

Hi AntonioCampanario,
I understand your frustration. I am working in the team that developing the wind analysis as a software engineer. We have started to investigate your case and we struggle to find out why this specific case does not succeed. 

It's a bit of a mystery for us to understand why this proposal did not succeed and we will need some time to understand why it does not work. 

[jon.ryfetten]

Hi AntonioCampanario,
I understand your frustration. I am working in the team that developing the wind analysis as a software engineer. We have started to investigate your case and we struggle to find out why this specific case does not succeed. 

It's a bit of a mystery for us to understand why this proposal did not succeed and we will need some time to understand why it does not work. 

[AntonioCampanario]

Thanks for the feedback.

Do hope you can find and solve the issue a.s.a.p.

If you need additional info about hardware, software, weather conditions, or anything else, just shout out and i will be happy to provide the info to you.

[AntonioCampanario]

Thanks for the feedback.

Do hope you can find and solve the issue a.s.a.p.

If you need additional info about hardware, software, weather conditions, or anything else, just shout out and i will be happy to provide the info to you.

[per.wessel.noreCT6K6 · Accepted solution]

Hi!

We found the issue, and have just resolved it. We have confirmed that the analysis succeeded in your project. You can see the analysis here. We did not rerun all your failed analyses, but it should work if you trigger new ones.

Kind regards, Per 

[per.wessel.noreCT6K6 · Accepted solution]

Hi!

We found the issue, and have just resolved it. We have confirmed that the analysis succeeded in your project. You can see the analysis here. We did not rerun all your failed analyses, but it should work if you trigger new ones.

Kind regards, Per 

[AntonioCampanario]

Hi Per,

I'll have a quick look.

Just started a new analysis after putting back the vegetation...

Thanks a bundel for the repair!

Antonio

[AntonioCampanario]

Hi Per,

I'll have a quick look.

Just started a new analysis after putting back the vegetation...

Thanks a bundel for the repair!

Antonio