Community
Civil 3D Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Civil 3D Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular AutoCAD Civil 3D topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Whenever I right click a pipe and select apply rules, pipe visually disconnects from catch basin. Same thing happens when I try to add a pipe from this structure.

13 REPLIES 13
SOLVED
Reply
Message 1 of 14
mterrell_Y4ETRUSA4HUR
794 Views, 13 Replies

Whenever I right click a pipe and select apply rules, pipe visually disconnects from catch basin. Same thing happens when I try to add a pipe from this structure.

I a photo of what I am talking about. I found out the issue is my structure not my pipes. Whenever I right click and apply styles on pipes connected to other structures, it works perfectly. There is some setting I don't know about or maybe it is the way my block is set up, but something about this particular structure is causing the pipes to visually disconnect from the structure. The pipes are still connected hydraulically because if you right click and try to reconnect pipe to structure, it tells you that there already connected. This issue is 100% the structure, I just don't know how to fix this. The pipes should be connected to the inner walls of the structure, as this is what I set up in the pipe properties. I attached my design file so you can see

Labels (2)
13 REPLIES 13
Message 2 of 14

Here is the file

Message 3 of 14

Question to Clarify-  When you say right click to apply styles there isn't a direct right click for that.  Are you talking about applying rules? 


I spend time on this forum because I enjoy Civil 3d and getting your likes.

Check out my Civil 3d blog at: http://c3dk.com/
Favorite Posts: Use Dynamo For Surface Analysis: https://youtu.be/eJNdX6guMP8
Message 4 of 14

Its also interesting when you look at this in object viewer, the two don't look anything alike.

brianstrandberg_0-1721427161360.png

 


I spend time on this forum because I enjoy Civil 3d and getting your likes.

Check out my Civil 3d blog at: http://c3dk.com/
Favorite Posts: Use Dynamo For Surface Analysis: https://youtu.be/eJNdX6guMP8
Message 5 of 14

Oops I meant apply rules. Also I’m not sure how to delete a comment on here so that is why one of my comments just has a period.

Message 6 of 14

.

Message 7 of 14

Wow that is so weird that in object view the pipe connects to different side of catch basin than plan view. I’ve never seen that before.

Message 8 of 14

You are using a block to represent the structure and it is not rotated correctly. In the image below I changed your structure style to show the outer part boundary instead of a block. On the left is your block rotated the same 0 degrees. If you want to use the block instead of the outer part boundary you need to recreate it at the correct rotation. 

 

strc.png

EESignature


Message 9 of 14

So I want the pipes to come out the long side of the catch basin (11 feet wide), not the short side (3.666 feet wide). You’re saying I need to rotate my block 90 degrees I think? What do I need to rotate my block to be?

Message 10 of 14
user181
in reply to: user181

Yes explode a copy of the block and rotate 90 degrees and recreate it or use bedit and rotate it around the insertion point . 

 

Drawing attached with the block recreated to match rotation of the structure.

 

 

EESignature


Message 11 of 14

You are a life saver. Thank you so much!

Message 12 of 14
brian.strandberg
in reply to: user181

Nice - I didn't think to check for that.  Good Catch.


I spend time on this forum because I enjoy Civil 3d and getting your likes.

Check out my Civil 3d blog at: http://c3dk.com/
Favorite Posts: Use Dynamo For Surface Analysis: https://youtu.be/eJNdX6guMP8
Message 13 of 14

Slight problem. I rotated block like you said and I noticed something. When I rotated block and put insertion point at middle of block, all pipes automatically snap to the middle of the structure. I attached a photo of this, but I want 2 pipes connected to the structure, so the pipes wont be in the middle of the structure. Is there a way to get the pipes to show up like what I have on the photo, and still be able to right click on a pipe and select apply rules and it applies the rules properly.

Message 14 of 14

This is error I get when I moved pipe to another insertion point on the structure, and tried to apply rules.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Rail Community


 

Autodesk Design & Make Report