Community
Civil 3D Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Civil 3D Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular AutoCAD Civil 3D topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

InfoDrainage - Network Design Wizard - Pipe Size Library

0 REPLIES 0
Reply
Message 1 of 1
douglas_macleod
135 Views, 0 Replies

InfoDrainage - Network Design Wizard - Pipe Size Library

douglas_macleod
Explorer
Explorer

Hi All,

 

I'm trying to figure out how the "Pipe Size Library" within the Network Design Wizard is intended to be used. To start, I've already prepared a pipe size library which is based on the minimum full bore velocity of 1m/s for each pipe diameter. See the attachment "Custom Pipe Size Library.png".

 

I cannot seem to get the Network Design Wizard to respect these figures. There must be some sort of hierarchy, behind the scenes, which determines which option/check box supersedes another. It's not immediately apparent.

 

If I uncheck the "Check Velocity" box, the design wizard will refer to the "Min. Slope (1:X)" and "Max. Slope (1:X)" at the bottom of the window. Does this not defeat the purpose of setting up your pipe size library in the first place?

 

It does seem that the most efficient solution to my issue is to just use the check velocity box and set it to a minimum of 1m/s. Write off using the pipe size library entirely. My only annoyance is that the the minimum gradients appear to be slightly steeper using this method.

 

For example - a 225mm dia. pipe can be set at 1:170 manually to achieve a 1m/s full bore velocity. However if you use the "Check Velocity" option within the wizard and set the minimum to 1m/s, it will give you a minimum gradient of 1:160. Minor difference admittedly but over a distance of 80metres, that's 30mm you could save downstream. 

 

Anyone have any insight?

 

Kind Regards,

Douglas

 

 

 

 

 

0 Likes

InfoDrainage - Network Design Wizard - Pipe Size Library

Hi All,

 

I'm trying to figure out how the "Pipe Size Library" within the Network Design Wizard is intended to be used. To start, I've already prepared a pipe size library which is based on the minimum full bore velocity of 1m/s for each pipe diameter. See the attachment "Custom Pipe Size Library.png".

 

I cannot seem to get the Network Design Wizard to respect these figures. There must be some sort of hierarchy, behind the scenes, which determines which option/check box supersedes another. It's not immediately apparent.

 

If I uncheck the "Check Velocity" box, the design wizard will refer to the "Min. Slope (1:X)" and "Max. Slope (1:X)" at the bottom of the window. Does this not defeat the purpose of setting up your pipe size library in the first place?

 

It does seem that the most efficient solution to my issue is to just use the check velocity box and set it to a minimum of 1m/s. Write off using the pipe size library entirely. My only annoyance is that the the minimum gradients appear to be slightly steeper using this method.

 

For example - a 225mm dia. pipe can be set at 1:170 manually to achieve a 1m/s full bore velocity. However if you use the "Check Velocity" option within the wizard and set the minimum to 1m/s, it will give you a minimum gradient of 1:160. Minor difference admittedly but over a distance of 80metres, that's 30mm you could save downstream. 

 

Anyone have any insight?

 

Kind Regards,

Douglas

 

 

 

 

 

Tags (1)
Labels (1)
0 REPLIES 0

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Rail Community


Autodesk Design & Make Report