Error during the solver launch

Error during the solver launch

Anonymous
Not applicable
2,316 Views
11 Replies
Message 1 of 12

Error during the solver launch

Anonymous
Not applicable

Hi! I'm a new CFD user. I've modeled a room like an example found in the Autodesk site: i've assigned materials, external conditions and i've setted the parameters for the Solver. In a few seconds i can see the "solution" but, when the iterations end, the solver crash. How can i solve this problem?Thank you for your attention.

Chiara Di Battista

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (2)
2,317 Views
11 Replies
Replies (11)
Message 2 of 12

Jon.Wilde
Alumni
Alumni
Accepted solution

I would guess something is wrong with the setup.

Firstly, are you running on a local drive? You probably need to be.

 

Other than that, we might need to see a support file (CFZ)

0 Likes
Message 3 of 12

Anonymous
Not applicable

Yes, i'm running on a local drive. In the attachment you can find my file CFZ.

Thank you 🙂

0 Likes
Message 4 of 12

Jon.Wilde
Alumni
Alumni

Thanks 🙂

 

I can see a few issues:

 

  • You cannot assign a flow rate and pressure to the same surface. One of the inlet/outlets just needs to have a P=0. I suggest that it should be the outlet.
    • The inlets then have a temperature and flow rate
  • You cannot assign internal (surface) boundary conditions like you have with the temperature. What is this representing?
    • One way to keep the temperature there would be to suppress the volume that it is applied to from the mesh
    • Another way of adding heat though, is to assign a volumetric heat load to a volume
  • Do you really need radiation on here?
  • It might be good to try refining the mesh - it looks a little coarse to me 🙂

 

Hope this helps,

Jon

0 Likes
Message 5 of 12

Anonymous
Not applicable

Ok, I've modified Outlet assigning only Pressure=0.

I've deleted the "External condition" Temperature assigned to the Volume of the internal air. If i''ll launch solver now will appair a notice that say there isn't a radiation face. I've tried to assigned to the Volume the "Boundary condition"  Total heat flow" (1000 watt) but i don't know if is it ok. 

I've unchecked "radiation" in the solver setup.

I've launch the solver but after the end of iterations it crash. 

In the attachments you can find the model modified.

 

Furthermore i've another problem (it seems i have only problem ahaha):

when i work in collaboration with other people, i can't  launch the solver before changing user in the control panel setting.

Can i easier work with a file created by another account?

Thank you for your very fast and helpfull answers.

 

Chiara Di Battista

0 Likes
Message 6 of 12

Jon.Wilde
Alumni
Alumni
Accepted solution

No problem 🙂

 

Here are a few more points:

 

  1. Your inlets and outlets are aluminium (they need to be air 😉 )
  2. The heat flux is still not OK - you could apply it to a solid but not a surface. What is this representing? 
  3. I am not sure what you mean about working with others, is this on your machine or others? Where is your licence held?
  4. You have insufficient mesh - any gap/outlet/duct etc needs at least 5-8 elements across its width - here you have only one (check out the webinar I ran on meshing, it might be useful)

Poor Mesh.jpg

 

Thanks,

Jon

0 Likes
Message 7 of 12

Anonymous
Not applicable

The problem was the air!!! Thank you! I've assigned air like materials to the inlets and outlets and the software doesn't crash anymore. 

We have two educational licenses in two different computer. If i create a new  CFD file and i send it to my friend , when he open my file the program say he can't launch the solver before changing some user's settings in the control panel. 

It happens because we have educational license?

I go to try the other advices you have sent yesterday and i'll tell you the effects. 😉

Thank you!! 🙂

 

0 Likes
Message 8 of 12

Jon.Wilde
Alumni
Alumni

I assume you are sharing a CFZ? They should all be created equally - are you finding the same behaviour if he opens a CFZ that he created himself?

I would expect the same to occur with any CFZ.

0 Likes
Message 9 of 12

Anonymous
Not applicable

The problem appear when i create a CFD file and i send it to someone else. When he open the CFD or CFZ and he launch the solver it will appear on him pc the Notice to change user settings. It seams like if only who create the new file can use it. 

When i sent you my file have you opened it and launched the solver without change your user settings?

 

0 Likes
Message 10 of 12

Jon.Wilde
Alumni
Alumni

Yes, I can run this (once I changed the solid to air) 🙂

 

Does your colleague find the same whatever file he runs? 

Can you share an image of the error he sees?

0 Likes
Message 11 of 12

Anonymous
Not applicable

Jon the problem was that we were opening the file situated in a shered folder. We've tried to copy the file on the desktop and now we are able to launch the solver without modify any settings 😉

Thank you so much, your support is very helpfull. 

We go to send you other question when we'll find other problem 😄

Message 12 of 12

Jon.Wilde
Alumni
Alumni

Yup, that was my next question (but I asked it above and didn't want to repeat myself 🙂 ).

 

Glad it's sorted, speak next time!

 

Thanks for the feedback

Jon

0 Likes