external references - how do i remove an unloaded xref? Purge won't let me

[atribo141141]

I have an unloaded external reference I wish to remove from the drawing file.  I have been successful with detaching or unloading xrefs followed by purging in some order that has worked for me previously.  This one though won't let me purge it.  What am i overlooking?

Also in the same discussion, is there a way to count the number and/or types of xrefs in a drawing file?

Thank you in advance.

[Joltremari]

<Xref> right click it <Detach> should work. Could you be more specific about the issue.

[atribo141141]

I have tried that, yes.  The details are that I created an xref for use in the drawing file.  When I changed the name of that xref, that xref became unreferenced or similar and has a red mark next to it now.  I have tried to right click menu to remove as well as the drop down menu.  I have been able to get them out before by doing a similar process of detaching/unloading/purging to get it removed from the xref menu, but this one I cannot remove.

[pendean]

Is it an XREF inside another XREF by chance? Those 'child' xrefs need to be removed by opening the 'parent' XREF to detach, you can't do it from the topmost file.

[atribo141141]

Hmm.  This could be the case.  If when I created this file, I copied it from another project which had xrefs contained, perhaps this would result in this way.  I can avoid this going forward and see if I encounter again.  Thank you both for your help.

[CGriffin]

When you open the External Reference Manager dialog box, click one of the icons on the upper RH corner for tree view to see if one is nested in another.

[atribo141141]

I have looked at the tree view and it appears it is not inside of another.  I've screenshot the issue and will see if the attachment comes thru.  Maybe you will see something I don't.  Thank you for your help.

[CGriffin]

I've had some that were stubborn for no good reason... 😉

Can you RELOAD it & then DETACH it?

[atribo141141]

I have definitely tried.  I just now tried to select a new path, and loaded another xref in its place to see if that would then allow me to control it and remove it.  No luck.  I will create my file differently next project to avoid this sequence.  Thank you all for your help.

[pendean]

Try this freeware add-on https://apps.autodesk.com/ACD/en/Detail/Index?id=5474554872375064722&appLang=en&os=Win32_64

[dbroad]

You probably nested it into another block definition.  

First, you should reload it so you can see where it is.  If you no longer have the xref, you can point the path to another file so at least you can see it.  Delete the internal block references and then you should be able to detach.

[atribo141141]

I have tried that just now.  I selected a new path for the file so I could at least see it and work with it in some way.  The new path I used led to a file with no internal block references so there was no change in the result.  Thank you for your help.

[dbroad]

Good.  My point though, was that your xref may have been accidentally nested into an internal block definition.  This can happen when you copyclip and then pastespecial as a block.  Doing that makes it impossible to detach the xref until the container block references are deleted AND then the internal block definition purged from the drawing.  It doesn't matter about the internal references of the undetachable xref.

[CGriffin]

Ironically... I had this very issue today.

I received a drawing from a vendor that had 12 xrefs and 10 would detach--2 were "stuck".

After I detached the 10, I saved my file and then systematically erased small sections of the file and then purged. Doing this (and not saving) let me figure out roughly where in the drawing the referenced file is stuck. In my case, I had one portion of the drawing I wanted to keep, so I ended up deleting everything else. Purged. Stubborn xrefs gone.

[andkal]

To detach unloaded xrefs you can try this short lisp routine from this thread:
https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/visual-lisp-autolisp-and-general/detach-unloaded-xrefs-routine/td-p/8...

[_anonandon]

does this link still work??

[CGBenner]

@_anonandon 

Which link are you referring to?  There are several shared throughout the life of this thread?

[andkal · Accepted solution]

;Mishler, Jeff 
(defun c:remove-unloaded-xrefs ()
(vlax-for block (vla-get-blocks
    (vla-get-activedocument
    (vlax-get-acad-object)))
    (if (and (= :vlax-true (vla-get-isxref block))
                 (= 0 (vla-get-count block))
          );and
         (vla-detach block)
    );if
);vlax for
);defun

[_anonandon]

thanks, hopefully that was the one i was referring to!! I'll check when my machine unfreezes

[CGBenner]

@_anonandon Did the information provided answer your question? If so, please use Accept Solution so that others may find this in the future. Thank you very much!