Reinforcement

Reinforcement

Nairi85
Advocate Advocate
1,965 Views
22 Replies
Message 1 of 23

Reinforcement

Nairi85
Advocate
Advocate

Good day!

Please see why this turns unrealistically high reinforced concrete columns ???
Theoretical and actual reinforcement differ from each other dozens of times !!
Reinforcement do according to the norms of Europe, the version of the program RSA 2015 SP5.
Calculation file attached to the letter.
thanks in advance. 

 

Снимок1.JPG

 

 

Снимок2.JPG

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vote please, for the good and important idea 🙂


nairisargsyan.com

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (2)
1,966 Views
22 Replies
Replies (22)
Message 21 of 23

Nairi85
Advocate
Advocate

The results of Spectral analysis  (СНРА II-6.02-2006) 

RSA 2015  SP5

 

1.jpg

 

2.jpg

 

3.jpg

 

4.JPG

 

5.JPG

 

6.JPG

 

7.JPG

 

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vote please, for the good and important idea 🙂


nairisargsyan.com

0 Likes
Message 22 of 23

Nairi85
Advocate
Advocate

Good day! I have a small request to the engineers of the forum who own program Lira Sapr. I beg you to do two test calculation:
1. Seismic calculation code СНРА II-6.02-2006.
2. Spectral calculation
All the necessary baseline and spectrum file can be downloaded at the following link:  https://yadi.sk/d/TW361XlIgJhCr

I very much hope that the comparison of these three calculations solve my problem.
Thank you.

 

8.jpg

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vote please, for the good and important idea 🙂


nairisargsyan.com

0 Likes
Message 23 of 23

Nairi85
Advocate
Advocate

The calculation results in Lira Sapr coincided almost 100%.I have not introduce to what to do with the reinforcement Smiley Sad

 

Тест А Лира результаты1.jpg

 

Тест А Лира результаты2.jpg

 

Тест А Лира результаты3.jpg

 

Тест А Лира результаты4.jpg

 

Тест А Лира результаты5.jpg

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Vote please, for the good and important idea 🙂


nairisargsyan.com

0 Likes