Seismic force plot and results verification

Seismic force plot and results verification

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast Enthusiast
827 Views
10 Replies
Message 1 of 11

Seismic force plot and results verification

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Good morning

 

I am a bit suspicious of my seismic analysis results and was wondering whether I may have missed something. To start with for some reason I can't manage to plot the seismic loads the code is generating even after running the analysis and having checked the right option under preferences.

 

antoniolafuente_0-1634808985019.png

 

Second, if I look at the reactions from the seismic load cases the values look pretty low for the close to 100 Ton of converted mass taken into account in the modal analysis and the response spectrum I'm using. 

 

antoniolafuente_1-1634809063394.png

antoniolafuente_2-1634809517468.png

Am I missing something? There seems to be something off with these results. I'm attaching anyway the file in case someone can have a quick look and give me a hand. Thanks a lot in advance

 

 

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (1)
828 Views
10 Replies
Replies (10)
Message 2 of 11

Romanich
Mentor
Mentor

Hi @antonio.lafuente ,

 

What I can see on Robot 2022, that you have execution error 2550  related to the eigenvalue problem (internal error while reading from a scratch file during eigenproblem analysis) 

Do you find the posts helpful? "LIKE" these posts!
Have your question been answered successfully? Click 'ACCEPT SOLUTION' button.

Roman Zhelezniak

Robot Evangelist & Passionate Civil Structural Engineer

LinkedIn | Robot & Хобот | App Store for Robot
EESignature


0 Likes
Message 3 of 11

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Strange. I don't have such error with Autodesk Robot 2020

0 Likes
Message 4 of 11

Simau
Mentor
Mentor
Accepted solution

Hi@antonio.lafuente 

Change the order of the load cases in order to have the seismic cases directly after the modal case.

 

Error 2550.png

 

M. Agayr
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

Message 5 of 11

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Hi!

 

That seems to have helped :). Thanks! I still can plot the forces though. Any idea on how to do this?

 

antoniolafuente_0-1634818958783.png

 

0 Likes
Message 6 of 11

Romanich
Mentor
Mentor

Romanich_0-1634823242160.png

 

Do you find the posts helpful? "LIKE" these posts!
Have your question been answered successfully? Click 'ACCEPT SOLUTION' button.

Roman Zhelezniak

Robot Evangelist & Passionate Civil Structural Engineer

LinkedIn | Robot & Хобот | App Store for Robot
EESignature


0 Likes
Message 7 of 11

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Thanks! Is this the only way? Can you not plot it in the load definition section? I though I had done this in the past or seen it done elsewhere

0 Likes
Message 8 of 11

Romanich
Mentor
Mentor

Hi @antonio.lafuente ,

 

In addition it is possible plot as added masses converted from the load:

Romanich_0-1634833180450.png

Or check results in the table:

Romanich_1-1634833242259.png

 

 

Do you find the posts helpful? "LIKE" these posts!
Have your question been answered successfully? Click 'ACCEPT SOLUTION' button.

Roman Zhelezniak

Robot Evangelist & Passionate Civil Structural Engineer

LinkedIn | Robot & Хобот | App Store for Robot
EESignature


0 Likes
Message 9 of 11

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Thanks! Bu t shouldn't I be able to see these forces when activating forces generated automatically?

 

antoniolafuente_0-1634883700899.png

 

0 Likes
Message 10 of 11

antonio.lafuente
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

Hi again Simau

 

I'm going through the results and maybe I'm missing a concept from the theory side, but shouldn't the spectrum applied on the X direction result in reactions only in the X direction? It is for the same model I attached in the beginning

 

Cheers

Antonio

 

antoniolafuente_0-1634895784424.png

 

0 Likes
Message 11 of 11

Simau
Mentor
Mentor

@antonio.lafuente 

nothing abnormal since your structure is not perfectly symmetrical in load and rigidity

M. Agayr
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

0 Likes