& Construction

Integrated BIM tools, including Revit, AutoCAD, and Civil 3D
& Manufacturing

Professional CAD/CAM tools built on Inventor and AutoCAD
Integrated BIM tools, including Revit, AutoCAD, and Civil 3D
Professional CAD/CAM tools built on Inventor and AutoCAD
Solved! Go to Solution.
Dear Artur
Greetings
Thank you for your clarification
Practically, in which case should I use (principle & complex) results?
Regards
Refaat
Principle:
when you want to see stress 'flow' or when you want to calculate Tresca stress (may be interested for masonry )
http://www.failurecriteria.com/misescriteriontr.html
Global/total displacements.
Complex:
von Mises stress, reinforcement calculations.
If you find your post answered press the Accept as Solution button please. This will help other users to find solutions much faster. Thank you.
I was pretty sure will get the perfect answer
Thanks a lot , Dear Artur
Refaat
Hi,
Can I consider a masonry wall as concrete column (h/t > 4) ?
My second question is how to define the interface between masonry wall and RC frame? I don't know if the concept "compatible nodes" (which present the stiffness of the interface) exist in Robot?
Thanks a lot
Hi
Thanks
Refaat
Auto-desk Robot is an amazing software, but it is a shame it does not have a masonry application. CMU walls are so abundant, it is hard to believe that Robot is still lacking in this aspect.
And please before you suggest any workarounds like defining panels, I suggest you firt familiarize with the design of masonry walls and acceptable software like IES Quickmasonry and the USA National Masonry Association's Structural Masonry Design Software
Hi @Artur.Kosakowski
I can't find where this diagram come from in your post on 05-16-2016 02:42 AM. Is it Diagrams for bars--Reactions tab?
The only thing I'd consider is to model a walls without openings and lintels and 'taking care' of them designing a wall separately (e.g. in some calculator) based on reduced forces obtained from Robot.
@Artur.Kosakowski in this case, can you apply a custom material considering the specific CMU mechanical properties calculated aside, and then using the full rigidity in both directions, vertical and horizontal, or would you reduce the horizontal Young Modulus? Considering that you have no openings and the walls are fully pinned at the bottom.
How to buy
Privacy | Do not sell or share my personal information | Cookie preferences | Report noncompliance | Terms of use | Legal | © 2025 Autodesk Inc. All rights reserved
Type a product name