Delauney + Regular mesh - Imprecision

Delauney + Regular mesh - Imprecision

Rafacascudo
Mentor Mentor
398 Views
1 Reply
Message 1 of 2

Delauney + Regular mesh - Imprecision

Rafacascudo
Mentor
Mentor

Model is for a small bridge all done with panels. Structure is perfectly symmetric as it is also for all of the identical nodal supports that are blocked in Uz and have very weak spring on Ux and Uy global directions, just to bypass instabilities warnings. Only load case is Self weight generated by the program.

Different mesh methods  and different results . I only noticed because my 1st mesh option for all panels was the one that caused the illogical results ,which was "Delauney + regular mesh selected" which is shown in the pic below

 

Delauney+regular mesh.jpg

Tried to find the cause by checking the whole simple geometry again. but couldn´t find the error.

But changing the mesh method did the trick . Below ,results without regular mesh selected which gave very near perfect results ,and far below the 3rd pic with Coons method which was the only one that gave perfect symmetrical reactions

Delauney NO regular mesh.jpgCoons.jpg

I Know that for this model the differences between the results are negligible , at least for Self weight load case.

But , still , it is a very simple and small model . I wonder what will happen with very large models for symmetrical and also unsymmetrical structures . Will "Delauney + regular mesh" mesh method be reliable??

 

Rafael Medeiros
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.

EESignature

399 Views
1 Reply
Reply (1)
Message 2 of 2

rokas_varanauskas
Advocate
Advocate

I have done a check on the model I'm currently working on and found similar trend, where by changing meshing method I get different results from the same load case in the same nodes, but in this instance is displacement rather than reactions. 

rokas_varanauskasarcadis_com_0-1701878523923.png

Robot version 2024 with details below (just updated to hotfix 1 few hours ago) 

rokas_varanauskasarcadis_com_1-1701878573338.png

 

0 Likes