Announcements
Welcome to the Revit Ideas Board! Before posting, please read the helpful tips here. Thank you for your Ideas!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Steel profile (structural framing) volume/mass differs from internet/book table data up to 5-7% (in medium detail level!)

Steel profile (structural framing) volume/mass differs from internet/book table data up to 5-7% (in medium detail level!)

Hi! 
I have found that steel profile (structural framing) volume/mass differs from table data. 
This is because Revit calculates volume only by medium detail level of cross section. For example, if it is closed section like rectangular hollow section (RHS), then in medium detail level cross section is box without radii - volume is apox. 5-7% bigger. 

If it is open beam section (H, I or U), then in medium detail level cross section is like welded plates without radii - volume is apox. 5-7% smaller.
In small projects mass difference of 5-7% is not significant, but in big project Customer offen checks total mass by table data from internet/book. For example 7% from 500 000kg is 35 000kg!
Taking volume from Schedule Material takeoff is not a good idea i think, if we need to do Structural Framing Schedule with steel beam dimensions, count and mass.
In short - please let us do volume/mass count by FINE detail level cross section.

1 Comment
piotr_pysz
Autodesk

Hi @roman.hruljov , thanks for the feedback. 
Please note that your Idea is part of the project that we are currently working on.
Please check the public roadmap - In progress tab. There is a card called 'Enhanced weight & length parameters for steel design, estimation, and procurement'.


Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea  

Autodesk Design & Make Report