Announcements
Welcome to the Revit Ideas Board! Before posting, please read the helpful tips here. Thank you for your Ideas!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

"Snap" topo surface to bottom of floor.

"Snap" topo surface to bottom of floor.

I do a lot of work on hillsides, which means that I have a complicated situation with the dirt beneath the floors.  I deal with this mostly by creating split surfaces and deleting them, then using filled regions on the elevations and sections, but this is less than satisfactory.  Maybe I am going about this all wrong, but I would like a command that snaps the top of the topo surface to the bottom of the floor.

3 Comments
Anonymous
Not applicable

That is what "pads" are for. They hollow out a topo surface or extend a surface to the underside of the pad.

johnharwood5
Enthusiast
I have discovered that command. Didactic learning tends to have gaps. Thanks a lot, I will do som e searching

gccdesign
Collaborator

I have pretty much stopped using pads. I use split surfaces instead. Again, like OP, hillside work.

Some pads are on grade then extend past the grade into the air. Pads will suck the topo up to the underside of the pad. You often don't want this.

Also pads are very finicky. They can't overlap a split topo. They can't overlap each other. Getting them to snap to the correct edge is not reliable enough. The snapping has a looser tolerance than Revit's error tolerance.

The elevation points of a topo region that are covered by a pad still exist and still influence the surrounding topo (via triangulation). In "real life" as in real dirt this is not the case. So I have found split surface to more reliable, less Revit warnings.

Sometimes if you have split surfaces and add a pad to the project it will automagically merge some of your other split surfaces. I went over this issue with tech support, it was reproduced, but no solution at this time.

So making the points snappable to a horizontal element like underside of slab would be very helpful. Also the snapping to contiguous topo surface edges is pretty dodgy. That could use some improvement.

 

Floor points have up and down draggable handles that can snap to things. This would be useful for topo points.

 

GChapp

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea  

Autodesk Design & Make Report