Announcements
Welcome to the Revit Ideas Board! Before posting, please read the helpful tips here. Thank you for your Ideas!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Do not reset the zoom after canceling a command

Do not reset the zoom after canceling a command

Hello,

The idea is simple: do not reset the zoom after canceling a command.

You are drawing, making adjustments, checking if everything looks good. You press Escape when you finish, but the view resets to the one from the last click.

Very annoying.

11 Comments

Hi, @fruity101079,

 

Can you give me a few more details or the steps to reproduce the issue? This sounds more like a bug.

 

Thank you!

adaversa
Contributor

@kimberly_fuhrman-jones  I take it you have not actually used Revit before? 😅

 

Steps to reproduce:

  1. Be in floor plan view, zoomed out
  2. Start filled region command
  3. Zoom in
  4. Click cancel/red X
  5. Revit automatically resets your zoom/extents to the state before filled region was started

Works with dimension strings and revision clouds, and I'm sure a whole host of others.

 

I don't usually find this a problem since it's been doing this for as long as I've used Revit, though it does annoy me at times.

Mark_Engwirda
Collaborator

@kimberly_fuhrman-jones its a unwanted behaviour, not a bug.

It only applies to  when you cancel creating or editing an object.

@adaversa ,

Please don't insult me. I have used Revit in architectural practice for over 18 years. I was unable to reproduce the issue you have. (in other words, the zoom did not reset for me after canceling the command when creating or editing an object.) The more details you can give our team, the easier it will be for us to try and help you.

 

Thank you.

 

adaversa
Contributor

Ok. @fruity101079 please feel free to add additional specific scenarios where this behavior occurs, the simplest case for demonstration purposes I've found is cancelling a filled region. Most of the others are cancelling sketches, and cancelling out of placing a spot elevation, for instance. Cancelling (pressing escape) walls, detail lines, and text notes does not exhibit this behavior.

 

Here's the issue demonstrated in Revit 2018:

Revit2018.gif

 

In Revit 2022:

Revit2022.gif

 

In Revit 2023:

Revit2023.gif

 

In Revit 2024:

Revit2024.gif

 

In Revit 2025:

Revit2025.gif

@adaversa ,

Thank you. The additional details and videos are very helpful. I will report this to our teams.

 

Have a great day!

fruity101079
Collaborator

Lots of comments I didn't see.

So yes, this is a behavior that occurs with any command. My example: draw a duct or a wall, anything, while leaving the command active, move around the plan, then press escape (or right-click/cancel). The zoom returns to where the duct (or wall or anything else) was drawn.

Mark_Engwirda
Collaborator

@kimberly_fuhrman-jones  I shouldn't have said thats its an "unwanted" behaviour, it's really a combination of Revit behaviour and individually workflows.   Some will like it and some won't.

 

fruity101079
Collaborator

@Mark_Engwirda  No, you're right. If the developers were users, many of the "complaints" mentioned wouldn't exist. Simply using the software is enough to notice all the UI inconsistencies.

adaversa
Contributor

@fruity101079Honestly, as much as we like to meme on this forum, a lot of architects leave to become Autodesk employees. Whether or not those same people are empowered by Autodesk to fix bugs to improve the software experience, or are instead redirected by the almighty monopoly power to compete with other things (like Procore), is another question. Autodesk has architecture locked in, and users get just enough of a trickle of new features (not bugfixes) to keep people from leaving. You and I are both complaining here instead of the Graphisoft forums, so mission accomplished.

 

In any case, despite my attempt at humor with my comment to Kimberly above, this is a "bug" that you only notice if you're new to the software, or if you've been using it since it was owned by RTC, and at that point you've been stockholm syndrome'd into just accepting that this is the way it's always worked, like @Mark_Engwirda said. I saw your comment and had to verify it for myself before realizing "yes, I am subconsciously frustrated by this, but consciously have come to accept and ignore it." For that reason I'd put fixing this low on my priority list versus things like legend views which are basically non-functional and have been ignored for years...or path of travel lines which, to show what US AHJs require, are actually modeled as railings, and railings, which are actually modeled as filled regions to avoid the brain damage of dealing with how Revit treats railings on stairs.

 

 

fruity101079
Collaborator

@adaversaYou put it low on your priority list, but actually, this is the kind of bug that can be fixed very quickly, just like other minor bugs that annoy users. Like the 3D orbit's pivot point.

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea  

Autodesk Design & Make Report