Worknc vs. Powermill- Which one wins?

Worknc vs. Powermill- Which one wins?

johnc4668
Advocate Advocate
3,129 Views
9 Replies
Message 1 of 10

Worknc vs. Powermill- Which one wins?

johnc4668
Advocate
Advocate

Looking for someone who has used both softwares and what you like and dislike about both of them. We have currently powermill for our edm dept. and worknc for our steel cutting dept. We are thinking about switching over to powermill for everything but Im looking for honest opinions from real world users before we do. Thanks! 

0 Likes
3,130 Views
9 Replies
Replies (9)
Message 2 of 10

karan30782
Advocate
Advocate

Hi ! @johnc4668 

 

POwermill is world's best application for manufacturing parts

 

Regards,

0 Likes
Message 3 of 10

Jonathan_Artiss19
Advisor
Advisor

@johnc4668 

 

Doesn't even compare. 

Jonathan Artiss
Senior Applications Engineer | DSI

Autodesk Expert Elite member
DSI, Design and Software International Autodesk Gold Partner

Message 4 of 10

Jonathan_Artiss19
Advisor
Advisor

@johnc4668 

 

Sent you a private message, if you care to discuss. 

Jonathan Artiss
Senior Applications Engineer | DSI

Autodesk Expert Elite member
DSI, Design and Software International Autodesk Gold Partner

Message 5 of 10

minh.lenhat
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

The most honest answer will come from you, so why not take a month trial.

Let's share the most complicated part you need to machining and let other users tell you they can do that with PowerMill or not.

And also what are the reasons that you want to leave WorkNC?

Le Nhat Minh
Senior Manufacturing Consultant
OneCAD Viet Nam Co., Ltd
Process Manufacturing
Message 6 of 10

5axes
Advisor
Advisor

PowerMill is a smart program for smart users

WorkNC is an automatic software used to produce a safe and automatic GCode

Both have strengths and weaknesses but the most important thing on my point of view is the level of the users who can determine the choice of one solution or the other.

Message 7 of 10

johnc4668
Advocate
Advocate

Thanks for all the info guys, We are slowly transitioning to powermill. Id say were split 50 50 using powermill and worknc now. I am finding that powermill is great in giving the user lots of options with toolpathing. Also its bad with giving the user lots of options with toolpathing 🙂

Message 8 of 10

minh.lenhat
Enthusiast
Enthusiast

With PowerMill, user can do anything with toolpath so they must know what they are doing and what they need.

You will see the advanced of PowerMill when you demand more dedicated toolpath and literally doing anything with that.

Le Nhat Minh
Senior Manufacturing Consultant
OneCAD Viet Nam Co., Ltd
Process Manufacturing
0 Likes
Message 9 of 10

cheidenfelder
Advocate
Advocate

I would do some serious testing. Powermill has been getting slower with every new version. I get more crashes now than ever before too. I never used work NC but a coworker did and he really liked it. I really like powermill but since version 16 its been going down hill. Just my 2 cents.

0 Likes
Message 10 of 10

johnc4668
Advocate
Advocate

@cheidenfelder good to hear your side. I have been using it for almost 15 years now. Worknc is easy and safe to use imo. BUT powermill is so much more functional and gives the user more options than wnc

0 Likes