Maya 2022.1 crashing when extruding poly + bugs

[rafaelsegnini]

Hello!
I'm having some problems regarding Maya 2022.1. I found that posting the bugs here could help solve some problems in the future.

Bug 1 - Maya is crashing every time I extrude a face or an edge in a orthographic view; Display is set to OpenGL - Core Profile (Compatibility).
Bug 2 - When applying a lattice selecting vertexes of an object, the deformer won't have any influence if the object has history nodes connected to it. This was never an issue, but strangely it is in the latest version of Maya.

Well, all the bugs are easily reproduceable. Hope someone can take a look into it.

Regards!

[LStirk]

I am also having constant crashes with extruding and bridging polys in 2022.1. I'm now having to save before any extrude or bridge operation. 

[hgarrou2]

Same here, I crash very often when extruding edges with Maya 2022.1.

2X GTX 2080Ti

Windows10 Pro

AMD 3970X 

128GB RAM

[brentmc]

Thanks. I have raised these issues with the relevant teams.
--

Brent

[mcginnc]

Hi - thanks for the info about your system & display, but can I get more details around your workflow, setup, etc. 

Is caching on or off?

Are you using smart extrude?

If you turn off the In View Editor (IVE) (Display -> HUD -> In-View Editors), still crash?

If you delete history on the object, still crash?

What is your UI layout (i.e. is the UV editor displayed) -> any floating or docked windows?

Does this happen in all scenes or one particular scene (or object)?

Any warnings before a crash?

Does Maya crash with a CER? If so, can I get the number?

If you do have a reproducible piece of geometry, would it be possible to send it to us?

Thank you!

[mcginnc]

Oh also, did this happen in previous versions you've used or is this a new problem? Same system/graphics card?

[hgarrou2]

I'lll be checking all of this right away. I have, however, found the workaround is to use the extrude from  the Modeling Toolkit instead and it never crashes......same computer, same setup(caching etc)   not sure what that means, but it got me through last night.

[mcginnc]

Hmmm, strange. I'll have to find out what the diff could be.

So going to Edit Mesh -> Extrude works? Do you use the ctrl+e hotkey at all? 

[hgarrou2]

First Extrusion Often works
Not Smart Extrude, my crashes have been while invoking extrude from the menu (i think exclusively)
Smart Extrude seems to work fine
Modeling Toolkit Button Always works
No caching, I'm working in DG evaluation mode, which tends to make my display panels update more accurately.
Deleting history doesn not help.
Workspace is typically a modified General, I do have floating windows in general, the refernece editor, tool settings panel, Render Settings and UV Toolkit are almost always floating on a second monitor.
All Scenes are apable of crashing so far
The only warning is a medium pause with no interactivity (about 2 seconds)
Using smart extrude or the tookit appear to fix the problem for a short period of time, then it comes back.

Hope this helps, I'll find a file that's currently crashing and attach to my nex posting.

[mcginnc]

Thank you! Will  have a look and try to repro what you've given me. 

[rafaelsegnini]

Oh, BTW, I realized that extruding in any view with smart extrude and with the objected isolated in the view will also crash Maya

[hgarrou2]

In all my fialures, I had some items hidden via layers while extruding.  That's not so different from object isolation.

Just a thought.

[rafaelsegnini]

Hmmm yes... Might be related...

I've observed that the smart extrude crash happens in any view, isolated or not isolated, and happens randomly. Might be related with the display layer also When Maya is freshly opened, it's not always that happens. But after working for a while will definitely happen.

This is a real crippling problem for classic modelers like me LOL 🙂
Yesterday I got about 30 crashes... 😞

[rafaelsegnini]

I've found out that poly bridge is also crashing Maya in the same manner.

[p0g0style]

Get crashes on Extrud/eBevel on very lowpoly Subdiv Models... Never got this in this sequence on Maya 2020/2022.0.  Happend on OpenGL Compatible/and Legacy mode but quite sure also on directX.

[rafaelsegnini]

In Maya 2022.2 all the problems listed here still persist. All the time...

[tugayisdas643GC]

It's been months since i first had this issue. Still no solution. It happens still.

[gobbgobb]

Using Maya 2022.2, still crashing randomly when extruding!

Not sure but I think it only happens when doing ctrl+E (not crashing when doing shift+move to extrude).

Had the same crash with the bevel also.

[mcginnc]

Hey - sorry for the delay and frustration. I have been trying to reproduce this, but no luck. Do you have a workflow that you use that consistently crashes? 

[gobbgobb]

Unfortunately no, it seems to be random, if I find any repro steps or scene I'll make sure to send them though.

Thanks