Solar Analysis Orientation Problem

Anonymous

Solar Analysis Orientation Problem

Anonymous
Not applicable

Hey All, 

I'm currently evaluating PV solar panels orientation on a certain roof, however i am facing a problem with orientation of panel, whatever the orientation of panels it keeps giving me the same insolation either it is facing true south or true north. 

 

I am new to this field and it is the first time i use such software, attached is different orientation showing the same result.

 

 

EAST.PNGNORTH.PNGSOUTH.PNG

0 Likes
Reply
Accepted solutions (1)
1,086 Views
5 Replies
Replies (5)

rds3000
Advocate
Advocate
Accepted solution

You're likely running into the limitation of Insight Solar that it can't correctly analyze insolation on faces that are within a Family or Group. 

 

Since porting the Solar engine from Vasari, a mass modeling tool, we haven't implemented the geometry transforms for faces inside Families and Groups, so the location of the face in Project Coordinates is relative to it's location in the Family Coordinates.  Also we neglected to filter the selection process to only allow selection of supported faces, and we just added a pop-up window describing this limitation when the 'Select Faces' button is checked (if all else fails, read the directions 😉 ).

 

So what you'll need to do is model your panels using standard Revit Elements like Wall, Ceiling, Roof, Floor or Mass.  

I prefer to use a Roof, as that makes it easy to experiment with tilt angle by manipulating pitch.  You can do a similar thing by modeling a Roof with a eave outline extrusion, or model with a mass built in a vertical reference plane so it can be tilted easily and maintain it's overall surface area.

 

There are a few other posts in the Forum about this issue that have some additional tips and examples.

 

David

Anonymous
Not applicable

Thanks rds3000, i used a roof and it changed.

 

Is there any future update that will clear such limitations ?  

0 Likes

rds3000
Advocate
Advocate

Yes, for sure, it's just a matter of priority vs resources.

First step will be to limit the selection function to only elements that are supported.  That will solve tons of UI problems.  Supporting elements in families and linked models and other things that are not in the primary document coordinate system is a bigger issue that will take more work.  It's entirely possible, but more effort, so more time.

David

0 Likes

craig_collins
Explorer
Explorer

Please limit the selections to only the supported elements. This is low-hanging fruit to reduce calculation error by the user.

rds3000
Advocate
Advocate

#1 on the Solar updates for the next release.  

0 Likes