spur gear: calculation indicates design failure

alexander.vdp1
Explorer
Explorer

spur gear: calculation indicates design failure

alexander.vdp1
Explorer
Explorer

hi,
i recently got an idea to design a planetary gear system. By using a book I bought for designing (and calculating) machine elements, I made some basic test calculations for the first gear transmission.
Z1 = 8 and D1 = 20mm

Z2 = 13 and D2 = 32.5mm

m = 2.5

center distance = 26.25mm

there are some design conditions so i cant just change 1 thing and make it work. It has to be a specific amount of teeth and not particulary a gear ratio. These values are important to make sure that overall, the planetary gears fit together. So they should be fixed.

 

alexandervdp1_0-1724931212322.png

alexandervdp1_1-1724931234819.png

alexandervdp1_2-1724931290564.png

 


When trying to add these calculations into the spur gear design tool in Inventor, i always get the same "calculation indicates design failure" message. Im not sure what causes this, i'm not a gear expert. But i think it has something to do with the life expectancy under certain conditions. But if that's the case, there is still no explanation to the generated gears going into eachother. It seems like the teeth always go into eachother. 
Would be nice if someone could explain to me what is causing this and how to fix it. 

 

 

0 Likes
Reply
212 Views
4 Replies
Replies (4)

alexander.vdp1
Explorer
Explorer

hey i would just like to update that i will be using a dxf gear generator and make them based on that. I have noticed the inventor spur gear generator is just not the right tool for generating real usefull gears.

0 Likes

CGBenner
Community Manager
Community Manager

@alexander.vdp1 

Hello, can you share wiht the group what version of Inventor you are using?  Would you be willing to share a file that demonstrates this?


Chris Benner
Industry Community Manager – Design & Manufacturing


If a response answers your question, please use  ACCEPT SOLUTION  to assist other users later.


Also be generous with Likes!  Thank you and enjoy!


Become an Autodesk Fusion Insider
Inventor/Beta Feedback Project

JDMather
Consultant
Consultant

@alexander.vdp1 

By default the gear generator creates simplified cosmetic toothforms.

There is an extra step to export correct involute toothforms.


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Autodesk Inventor 2019 Certified Professional
Autodesk AutoCAD 2013 Certified Professional
Certified SolidWorks Professional


CGBenner
Community Manager
Community Manager

@alexander.vdp1 Hello, do you still need help with this question?


Chris Benner
Industry Community Manager – Design & Manufacturing


If a response answers your question, please use  ACCEPT SOLUTION  to assist other users later.


Also be generous with Likes!  Thank you and enjoy!


Become an Autodesk Fusion Insider
Inventor/Beta Feedback Project