Model State Hole Edits Error

[jason.thielen]

Hello,

I am working to create a model state of a basic plate. The plate currently has holes with countersinks. After creating a new model state and turning off the scope that edits all model states, I try to remove just the countersink in the new model state. The countersink gets removed from all states. I can change size without the edit transferring over to all model states. 

Overall, can you not edit the hole seat (none, counterbore, countersink, spotface) without editing all model states? Is there other features that have missing functionality as well when it comes to model states? The only way I can think to get around this is to suppress the feature and fully remake the feature to the same sketch. This seams like not the way model states are meant to be utilized though.

Thank you

[jason.thielen]

Hello,

I am working to create a model state of a basic plate. The plate currently has holes with countersinks. After creating a new model state and turning off the scope that edits all model states, I try to remove just the countersink in the new model state. The countersink gets removed from all states. I can change size without the edit transferring over to all model states. 

Overall, can you not edit the hole seat (none, counterbore, countersink, spotface) without editing all model states? Is there other features that have missing functionality as well when it comes to model states? The only way I can think to get around this is to suppress the feature and fully remake the feature to the same sketch. This seams like not the way model states are meant to be utilized though.

Thank you

[kacper.suchomski · Accepted solution]

Hi

You have 2 ways:

1. Exclude holes and create new ones (without counterbores).
2. Delete Face and turn it off in one of the states of the model.

[kacper.suchomski · Accepted solution]

Hi

You have 2 ways:

1. Exclude holes and create new ones (without counterbores).
2. Delete Face and turn it off in one of the states of the model.

[Frederick_Law · Accepted solution]

MS can't control inside of every feature yet.

ie extrude boss to exturde cut.

I'll think it'll be difficult for someone else to edit the file since user can't see changes inside a feature.

Like same hole with CB, CS, tap, thru, blind in different MS.

So you'll need to suppress and unsuppress different features for now.

Do add Idea in the forum.

[Frederick_Law · Accepted solution]

MS can't control inside of every feature yet.

ie extrude boss to exturde cut.

I'll think it'll be difficult for someone else to edit the file since user can't see changes inside a feature.

Like same hole with CB, CS, tap, thru, blind in different MS.

So you'll need to suppress and unsuppress different features for now.

Do add Idea in the forum.

[jason.thielen]

thank you for the confirmation

[jason.thielen]

thank you for the confirmation

[jason.thielen]

thank you for the confirmation and I'll be sure to add it to the idea forum

[jason.thielen]

thank you for the confirmation and I'll be sure to add it to the idea forum